In January, every Democratic state senator in Virginia voted in favor of a bill intended to allow the town of Purcellville in Loudoun County to suspend a council member who had been indicted on felony charges.
Now those same Democratic state senators face an uncomfortable question: If thatโs good for Purcellville, then why isnโt it good for Portsmouth?
More to the point, should Democrats join Republicans in moving to require state Sen. Louise Lucas, D-Portsmouth, to step away from her position as chair of the Senate Finance Committee while she faces five federal felony charges related to accusations that she was running a criminal organization selling marijuana?
No one should hold their breath: This will not happen, which will only give Republicans more motivation to keep the issue before people.
The reason why Democrats will not displace is two-fold.
The first is the natural instinct for political parties to rally around their own no matter what.
The second is the F word: fear. Anyone who holds the gavel of the Senate Finance Committee is automatically one of the most powerful people in the state. By dint of personality, Lucas โ journalist David Poole recently described her as โa profane folk heroโ โ is more powerful than most. She single-handedly deep-sixed then-Gov. Glenn Youngkinโs pitch for a sports arena in Alexandria. Sheโs bedeviled Gov. Abigail Spanberger with her insistence that the state abolish its tax break for data centers eight years early.
No legislator wants to get on the wrong side of a chair of Senate Finance. No one wants to get on the wrong side of this chair of Senate Finance in particular. Republicans have the freedom to call for Lucas to give up her chairmanship because they figure theyโre already on her bad side. Democrats are definitely not going to risk it; just in case, the partyโs second-in-command in the Senate โ Sen. Mamie Locke, D-Hampton โ issued a warning to any Democrats thinking about displacing Lucas. โIt would be an awful precedent for us to take up a resolution against an individual who is presumed innocent,โ Locke saidย recently. Thatโs an excellent point about American jurisprudence but itโs not the standard that Locke and other Senate Democrats applied earlier this year to Purcellville. (Ironically, it was eight Senate Republicans who voted against the Purcellville bill.)
Just in case her warning wasnโt clear enough, Locke put the Lucas indictment in the context of other Trump administration indictments that some see as politically motivated. โWhy do so many powerful Black women who challenge political power find themselves having to defend not only their ideas, but their offices, their reputations, their careers and sometimes their very freedom?โ Locke said.ย
If any Democrats have reservations about having someone with felony charges hanging over them presiding over one of the legislatureโs most important committees, they will submerge them, never to be uttered in public.
The old political adage says that โif you strike the king, youโd best not miss.โ Lucas is sometimes referred to as โthe queen,โ but the same principle applies. The catch: Even a successful attempt to remove Lucas would be politically messy, and Democrats would not want to deal with the aftermath.
For Republicans, that Democratic reluctance to act may be a better outcome than Democrats actually taking action: This gives them a talking point that they can take into next yearโs General Assembly elections.
Virginia Republicans have now been drubbed in two straight elections โ last year on affordability, this year on both affordability and corruption (related to the Trump administration). They no doubt see an opportunity now to turn the tables and use both issues against Democrats in 2027 โ to allege that Democratic policies havenโt lowered prices and then flash up pictures of Lucas with damning headlines. I suspect some Republican operative is at this moment rifling through photos to find images of every Democratic legislator with Lucas.
Republicans are finding multiple ways to push the issue.
Senate Republicans want a rule that requires โa committee leader indicted on a felony charge to step aside until the case is resolved.โ
State Sen. Bryce Reeves, R-Orange County, has gone further and introduced a resolution to expel Lucas โ a process that would start with a formal investigation by the Senate Privileges and Elections Committee.
Former Attorney General Jason Miyares โ a likely contender for governor in 2029 โ has sent a letter to Spanberger asking that she initiate a formal probe to see if Lucas committed any state crimes beyond the federal ones sheโs alleged to have committed. (See full text below.)
None of these things will happen, but they give Republicans plenty of oxygen to work with. I donโt doubt that Republicans believe all these things, but this is also delightfully opportunistic โ if the situation were reversed, with a Republican committee chair under federal indictment, it would be Democrats making the same moves.
Now we come to the educational part of our program: If Virginia were Georgia, none of this would be necessary. Thatโs because the Georgia Constitution sets out a procedure on how to deal with public officials who are charged with felonies. (It even has rules on how to deal with a governor who is charged with a felony!) In the case of a state legislator, the governor is directed to name a three-person committee โ consisting of the attorney general and one legislator from each chamber โ to investigate and produce a confidential written report within 14 days: โIf the commission determines that the indictment relates to and adversely affects the administration of the office of the indicted public official and that the rights and interests of the public are adversely affected thereby, the governor โฆ shall suspend the public official immediately and without further action pending the final disposition of the case or until the expiration of the officerโs term of office, whichever occurs first.โ
The most recent Georgia suspension happened in January after a state legislator had been indicted on felony charges related to allegedly lying about her employment to collect government pandemic funds. She later resigned and pleaded guilty.
If Virginia were Georgia, that commission would have already been empaneled and a secret report produced. We have no idea what would have happened then, although itโs likely Lucas might still be in office. Georgia lays out a three-part test, all connected by โand,โ which means all three parts must be satisfied. One of the charges against Lucas does relate to her office โ โconspiracy to commit honest services fraud.โ Thatโs simply a factual matter โ yes, thatโs the charge, so that first box can be ticked off. However, the other two parts are more subjective: Does her indictment โadversely affectโ her service and are โthe rights and interest of the public โฆ adversely affectedโ? I suspect on those two points opinions would vary.
That brings us to this: Unless youโre a town council member in Purcellville, thereโs no mechanism in Virginia law that prevents an official indicted on felony counts from continuing in office. Thereโs no recall provision for a state legislator; there are recall provisions for city council members or county supervisors, but the threshold for having an official removed is high. One reason for the emergency bill this year related to the Purcellville Town Council member โ the vice mayor, in fact โ was that he hadnโt been recalled.
In 2021, then-Roanoke City Council member Robert Jeffrey Jr. was indicted on felony counts; he continued serving for almost nine months before he pleaded guilty โ and then had to forfeit his council seat.
In Buchanan County, Supervisor Trey Adkins was indicted in 2022 on 82 felony counts, mostly related to alleged election fraud. Four years later, heโs still in office โ and the case has yet to come to trial. In between, he was also reelected by a landslide margin.
We live in a country where one of the operating legal principles is that someone charged with a crime is innocent until proven guilty. In some cases, yes, that can lead to some charged with felonies continuing to serve in public office.
The General Assembly changed that for Purcellville; should it change that for itself? Should it change that for everywhere?
Former Attorney General Jason Miyaresโ letter to Gov. Spanberger.
For even more political news and analysis, sign up for West of the Capital, our weekly political newsletter that comes out every Friday afternoon.

