Beth Macy may not have won her campaign for the U.S. House of Representatives, but she may have helped elect at least one and maybe two Democrats to the Roanoke City Council.
Or, perhaps more accurately, Macy may have indirectly helped block independents David Bowers and Stephanie Moon Reynolds from returning to the council.
Trigger warning: Math lies ahead!
In two previous columns this week, I looked at how the voter turnout patterns this year were dramatically out of balance in ways that benefited Democrats. Specifically, Republicans voted at roughly normal levels for a congressional midterm, but Democrats voted at near-presidential levels.
In some districts that were already close, that was enough to enable Democrats to oust Republican incumbents โ Shannon Taylor defeated Rob Wittman in the 1st District, and Elaine Luria defeated Jen Kiggans in the 2nd District. In other districts where Democrats lost, such as the 5th, 6th and 9th districts, those candidates simply ran out of Democratic voters before the Republican candidate ran out of Republican voters.
While the bottom line did not work out for those candidates, their ability to produce Democratic turnout at near-presidential levels was impressive. It also made me wonder: Were there any places where that dramatic level of Democratic turnout made a difference at the local level? The old adage applies even though we are well inland: A rising tide lifts all votes. Did this yearโs blue wave โ some prefer โblue tsunamiโ or โbluenamiโ โ elect some local Democrats who might otherwise not have won?
The numbers suggest thatโs what might have happened in Roanokeโs city council election.
Before I make my numerical case, Iโll go ahead and point out why I might be wrong. Roanoke is a Democratic city. The three Democratic candidates were always going to be favored simply because they were Democrats. No one should be surprised that the ticket of council member Vivian Sanchez-Jones and newcomers Raekwon Moore and Danny Clawson won. That was always the expected outcome.
However, the math suggests the Democratic sweep might not have been as automatic as we might think.
Letโs start with the last time these three particular council seats were on the ballot โ 2022.
The vote totals of the three winning Democrats that year were:
Joe Cobb: 12,485
Vivian Sanchez-Jones: 11,716
Peter Volosin: 9,672
The fourth-place candidate that year was Republican Nick Hagen, with 9,232 votes. (He went on to win a council seat two years later.)
Hereโs the math you need to remember. To win a council seat that year, a candidate needed 9,233 votes โ one more than Hagen got. While Volosin trailed the other Democrats by several thousand votes, he cleared that hurdle.
Now letโs see how many votes it took to win a council seat this year:
Raekwon Moore: 16,725
Danny Clawson: 13,144
Vivian Sanchez-Jones: 12,830

There were five other candidates, but the two who finished just out of the money in fourth and fifth are where we need to look:
David Bowers: 10,405
Stephanie Moon Reynolds: 10,400
The vote totals for those two candidates would have been enough for Bowers to win four years ago. All the winning candidates got more votes than the winning candidates did in 2022. Why? Because turnout was higher. Turnout was higher than the last midterms in every locality in Virginia. Statewide, it was up 21.7%. In Roanoke, the turnout jumped 26.2% โ one of the biggest spikes in the state. (Notice that Iโm focused here on how much turnout increased, not the actual percentage of voters who cast ballots. In Roanoke that was 48%, which is still on the low side in Virginia.)
Now letโs look at who drove that turnout in Roanoke higher this year than four years ago: It was Democrats.
In the 2022 elections, Roanoke had 26,320 people cast ballots in the congressional race between Republican Ben Cline and Democrat Jennifer Lewis.
This year, Roanoke had 33,237 voters. Thatโs an โextraโ 6,917 voters.
Letโs peel this onion back a little more.
This was the congressional vote in Roanoke four years ago:
Lewis: 15,482
Cline: 10,780
Now look at the congressional vote in Roanoke this year:
Macy: 23,115
Cline: 9,765
The Republican vote went down by about a thousand votes while the Democratic vote ballooned by 7,633 votes.
Clineโs vote drop was unusual. In the 6th District overall, he increased his vote tallies, thanks to strong performances in the rural parts of the Shenandoah Valley. That big boost of โnewโ Democratic voters is stunning. Technically, these werenโt โnewโ voters โ this is simply a case of Macy producing near presidential-level turnout and retaining almost every Kamala Harris voter from two years ago. In the context of a congressional midterm, they were โnewโ voters. So what impact did that have on the city council elections?
Logically, this puffed up the vote totals of all three Democratic council candidates.
It might also have helped increase Moon Reynoldsโ totals. Some of her best precincts were also Democratic precincts. She finished second in Lincoln Terrace, with Moore taking first and Sanchez-Jones third there. Moon Reynolds finished third in Eureka Park, Forest Park and Summit Hills. All those are predominantly Black precincts where Democrats typically win by landslide margins. In all those precincts, the Democrat who didnโt make the top three was Clawson, so Moon Reynolds appears to be responsible for knocking Clawson out of a winning position there. Clawson made up those votes with strong performances in the precincts in the southwest part of the city, enough to finish second overall.
But then thereโs Bowers. In theory, the higher Democratic turnout shouldnโt have helped him. He hasnโt run as a Democrat in a decade. More recently, heโs run multiple times as an independent and once as a Republican; three years ago, he announced heโd become a Republican, although this time he chose to run as an independent.
Itโs possible that Bowersโ reputation โ his โbrand,โ if you will โ overshadows any political affiliation. However, an inspection of Bowersโ precinct-by-precinct results shows that he ran strongest in the cityโs most Republican-inclined precincts and ran weakest in the most Democratic ones. This leads me to think that Bowersโ 10,405 votes had little to nothing to do with the strong Democratic turnout. That means Bowers likely would have won a council seat if the Democratsโ blue wave hadnโt lifted up the partyโs council candidates.

Moore ran so strongly that he seems likely to have won a council seat no matter what. The question is whether it was Clawson or Sanchez-Jones who benefited most from the Democratic trends and kept Bowers off the council. Thatโs hard to say.
Four years ago, Sanchez-Jones polled 11,716 votes. Even if all she did was hang onto those voters, that would have been enough to win this time. That leads to the question of whether the larger Democratic turnout this year is responsible for Clawson โ a newcomer to city politics โ winning.
Thatโs harder to say. However, second-place Clawson ran 2,739 votes ahead of fourth-place Bowers โ and this yearโs election had 6,917 โextraโ voters, who were, mathematically speaking, all Democrats.
The math doesnโt say more, but what it does say sure is interesting.
Want more interesting election maps? Weโll have it Friday in West of the Capital, our weekly political newsletter. For math-phobes: We have more than math, too.

