Poll workers speak with voters on Election Day outside of a polling location, Grove Park Preschool, in Danville. Photo by Grace Mamon.

Virginians were excited about voting this year.

This year saw 21.7% more Virginians cast ballots than during the last congressional midterms in 2022.

Some of that increase is due to population growth, of course โ€” but only a small part.

From the last midterms to now, Virginiaโ€™s population has grown just 2.9%.

Furthermore, turnout grew in every locality in Virginia, even the ones that are losing population. Since the last census, Buchanan County has lost population at a faster rate than any other county or city in the state, but this year its voter turnout was 16.9% over the last midterms. Thatโ€™s below the state average but still a pretty impressive increase for a shrinking locality.

Motivation might have varied from place to place and voter to voter, but whatever was motivating voters, they were much more engaged in this yearโ€™s elections than they normally are for a midterm.

In a column earlier this week, I documented how Republicans generally produced a normal midterm turnout โ€” or, in some cases, a little higher turnout โ€” but Democrats produced a near-presidential level turnout. (And in three localities, they exceeded presidential levels.) This is the so-called โ€œblue wave,โ€ but itโ€™s important to note that Republican voters werenโ€™t lethargic; they just couldnโ€™t match Democratsโ€™ enthusiasm levels, which were abnormally high for this election cycle.

In a separate column today, I look at how that rising blue tide may have lifted one or two Democrats into city council seats in Roanoke who otherwise might not have won. Did that happen anywhere else in Virginia? I havenโ€™t studied every locality, but it doesnโ€™t appear to have changed the outcomes in the major local elections in Southwest and Southside: Bristol, Danville, Lynchburg, Martinsville and Radford. In Lynchburg, Republicans might have been able to hold onto three council seats if they had a united ticket instead of two rival slates; I dealt with that math in a previous column, too.

Hereโ€™s the map

This shows how much voter turnout increased in each locality. Just hover over it, and youโ€™ll get the percentage increase.

Higher turnout likely turned Montgomery Countyโ€™s sheriffโ€™s race from a squeaker into a rout

The higher turnout does appear to have changed a potentially close sheriffโ€™s race in Montgomery County into a landslide for Democrat Tim Brown.

In the 2022 midterms, Democrat Taysha DeVaughn won Montgomery County by 14,239 votes to 13,563 for Republican U.S. Rep. Morgan Griffith. (Most of the district is overwhelmingly Republican, so Griffith skated to an easy reelection.)

This year Griffith increased his numbers in Montgomery County to 15,327 votes but Democrat Joy Powers turned out 23,315 (with Griffith again winning easily districtwide).

In the sheriffโ€™s race, Republican Robert Page polled 13,274 votes โ€” almost exactly what Griffith got four years ago and not quite all of what Griffith got this year. Pageโ€™s tally was a pretty consistent Republican showing for a down-ballot race. However, Brown polled 23,351 โ€” outrunning even his partyโ€™s congressional candidate.

Montgomery County had 39.8% more voters this year than four years ago, and it appears that almost all of them were Democrats. In 2022, using the basic party numbers, the sheriffโ€™s race might have been close, producing a narrow win for Brown. This year it gave him a landslide win.

What impact did the constitutional amendments have?

Did the three Democratic-backed constitutional amendments (which all passed) inadvertently cost Democrats a congressional seat? That question turns on the 5th District, where Republican John McGuire survived a close call from Democrat Tom Perriello. In a previous column this week, I examined the numbers and concluded that Perriello didnโ€™t underperform; he squeezed out virtually every Democratic vote that was available in the district. The problem for him was that McGuire overperformed and did a better job of turning out Republican votes than all but one other Republican congressional candidate in Virginia. Did those constitutional amendments contribute to McGuireโ€™s overperformance? In other words, did they rile up rural conservatives to go to the polls who otherwise might have stayed home?

I canโ€™t tell. Thatโ€™s certainly possible. However, while turnout increased everywhere, the increase in many rural localities was on the low side. Maybe even that limited increase was motivated by the amendments, not love for McGuire, but we really donโ€™t know. McGuire also spent a lot of time pushing a โ€œnoโ€ vote so itโ€™s not as if his campaign was divorced from the amendment votes. He also had a parade of top-name Republican surrogates campaigning for him. He was hardly a passive spectator to the campaign. Maybe the โ€œnoโ€ side helped his campaign some but he also helped himself โ€” campaigning hard and, based on the results, effectively.

What we do know is that the turnout increases were pretty consistent in Democratic localities but distinctly uneven in Republican ones. In the 5th District, the overall vote in Republican-voting Nottoway County was up 9.3% while it was up 23.2% in Campbell County. (That certainly helped McGuire because Campbell is much bigger than Nottoway.)

In some rural counties, the turnout increase was inexplicably low โ€” up just 2% in Highland and Rappahannock counties, up 3.3% in Madison County, up 4.3% in Southampton County. The โ€œnoโ€ side likely left votes behind there, although given the small populations involved, that would not have made the difference. Still, itโ€™s a curious inconsistency.

The biggest vote surges came in college towns, which Democrats focused on organizing. Williamsburg had the biggest increase in the state โ€” up 47.6%. That meant 1,960 votes for Democrat Shannon Taylor above what the Democratic candidate for the 1st District seat produced there four years ago. Harrisonburg was up 43.4%, Montgomery County up 39.8%, Radford up 38.8%.

One place with a big uptick in votes might seem unusual because itโ€™s a rural, Republican county: Dickenson County saw 30.4% more voters than four years ago. It also had a hotly contested election for commonwealthโ€™s attorney that helped drive turnout.

More people cast ballots in that race than voted on any of the constitutional amendments.

Yancey is founding editor of Cardinal News. His opinions are his own. You can reach him at dwayne@cardinalnews.org...