John Rocovich, former rector of the Virginia Tech Board of Visitors, has sued the university and Gov. Abigail Spanberger over his removal from the post. Courtesy of Virginia Tech.

A Richmond judge said he expects to rule after Thanksgiving on pretrial motions in the lawsuit that former Virginia Tech rector John Rocovich filed against the governor and Virginia Tech for what he claims was an illegal removal from his position.ย 

The timeline update came during an hours-long hearing on the case in Richmond Circuit Court on Wednesday. Attorneys from both sides argued over motions from Gov. Abigail Spanberger and Virginia Tech to throw out the case and over a motion from Rocovich to seek a ruling on his claims.ย 

Rocovich sat in a front row of the courtroom as his attorney, Thomas McCarthy, said the case hinged on due process.

Rocovich did not speak during the hearing and declined to provide any comment to Cardinal News afterward.

The case stems from Spanbergerโ€™s removal of Rocovich, a Roanoke attorney, from the Virginia Tech Board of Visitors in May for what she said were violations of the boardโ€™s code of ethics. He was replaced by Edward Baine, president of Dominion Energy, who is also named in the suit, as is Sharon Brickhouse Martin, whom Spanberger also appointed to the board.

[Disclosure: Dominion is one of our donors, but donors have no say in news decisions; see our policy.]

The suit was filed in Montgomery County in June and later was moved to Richmond.

Details of Rocovichโ€™s alleged ethics violations werenโ€™t included in his removal letter, and none have been provided by Spanberger since. A spokesperson for the governorโ€™s office could not be reached for comment Wednesday night.

McCarthy argued that Rocovich lost his right to property โ€” his seat on the board โ€” that was granted to him unless thereโ€™s a finding of โ€œmalfeasance, misfeasance, incompetence or gross neglect of duty,โ€ as detailed in state law. That loss of property triggers the due process clause, McCarthy said, even though the next part of the statute states that the governor can be the โ€œsole judgeโ€ of the reasoning for the removal.

โ€œThat doesnโ€™t change anything about [the] due process clause,โ€ McCarthy contended.

The lack of judicial review creates a violation of the separation of powers laid out in the constitution, McCarthy added, since the courts are stripped of their power to hold the governor accountable. But attorneys for Spanberger and Virginia Tech werenโ€™t having it.ย 

Michael Shebelskie of Hunton Andrews Kurth, who represented Spanberger, argued that the General Assembly wrote the law that allows the governor to appoint and remove board members, and then to be the โ€œsole judgeโ€ of the decision.ย 

โ€œThis is a political dispute between the General Assembly and the governor,โ€ Shebelskie said.ย 

Cullen Seltzer of Sands Anderson, representing Virginia Tech and the board members, supported Shebelskieโ€™s arguments and added that McCarthyโ€™s arguments canโ€™t be based on reading part of the statute and ignoring the rest of it. Further, the actions being challenged didnโ€™t originate from the school or its board, Seltzer argued.

โ€œAll of those actions were the governorโ€™s actions,โ€ Seltzer said.

Substitute Judge Michael McKenney didnโ€™t make a clear indication as to which side he favored, but he questioned McCarthyโ€™s argument that Rocovichโ€™s seat on the board was property he was entitled to.ย 

Part of the case law McCarthy cited to make that claim involved a public school security guard who was fired, thereby losing his pay and ability to have a livelihood. Rocovichโ€™s seat was a gubernatorial appointment, McKenney pointed out.

โ€œExplain that to me,โ€ the judge said, prompting McCarthy to argue that it didnโ€™t matter whether the position in question was paid or unpaid.

As for McCarthyโ€™s motion seeking a ruling on the case, lawyers for Spanberger and Virginia Tech argued that a decision would be premature since McKenney could rule to throw out the case on the motions, while direct arguments on the merits of the case havenโ€™t been made yet.

Charles Paullin is a Richmond-based writer focusing on energy and environment issues. He's written for...