During the fall campaign, President Donald Trump urged voters to vote as if he were on the ballot.
Many did. They were mostly Democrats.
The final numbers from the election in Virginia are now in (thereโs still counting underway in other states), and they give us a clearer understanding of what just happened.
Across Virginia, Democrats consistently voted at much higher rates than Republicans โ the only exception was Lancaster County, by the Chesapeake Bay. This was not necessarily a case of Republicans sitting out the election. In almost all localities, Virginia Republicans went to the polls this year at a higher rate than they did in the 2022 Joe Biden midterms. What happened instead was that Democrats voted at historic levels.
Broadly speaking, Democrats voted at near-presidential election levels while Republicans voted at levels that were about normal, or sometimes a little more than normal, for a midterm election. That imbalance in participation rates helps explain why Democrats were able to oust two Republican incumbents: Shannon Taylor defeated Rob Wittman in the 1st District and Elaine Luria defeated Jen Kiggans in the 2nd District.
Despite that imbalance in voting rates in their favor, Democrats were still unable to overcome three other Republicans: John McGuire in the 5th, Ben Cline in the 6th and Morgan Griffith in the 9th. Democrats came close in the 5th โ achingly close if youโre a Tom Perriello supporter โ but still couldnโt close the gap. A close inspection of the final numbers shows some of the dynamics at play beneath the surface of the totals, one of which is this: Even in the best year for Democrats since the Watergate elections of 1974, they still found it difficult to make headway with enough rural voters to win in districts with large rural populations. Thatโs why Perriello came up on the short end in the 5th District, while Democrat Beth Macy lost by a double-digit margin in the 6th District.
That may not be a lesson that Democrats are particularly concerned about now, as they prepare to take control of both chambers of Congress. However, itโs a lesson that, if not learned and not addressed, could come back to bite Democrats in future elections when the political winds are not so distinctly in their favor as they were this year. Put more bluntly: Democrats should not assume that some districts they just won have turned permanently blue. Some of this yearโs wins might prove to be quite temporary in a different political climate because the turnout pattern this year was so unusual.
Hereโs what I see when I crunch the numbers on this yearโs results:
All but one of the Republican incumbents received more votes this year than in the previous midterms

The only exception was Kiggans in the 2nd District, who lost. Other than the 2nd, the only districts where Republican vote totals went down from the 2022 midterms were districts that were strongly Democratic to begin with and the Republican standard-bearers were lightly funded. The point is that Republicans did not stay at home in the races that counted โ Wittman, McGuire, Cline and even Griffith in the solidly red 9th District received more votes than they did in the last comparable election. Even Kiggans was not far off her 2022 mark โ down 1,124 votes or a loss of 0.7% of her previous support. In a bad year for Republicans, four of the five Republican incumbents in Virginia grew their support from what had been a good year for Republicans in 2022, and the only one who didnโt see support increase saw it slip by such a small amount it might be insignificant. Mathematically, the only reason that Wittman and Kiggans lost is not that Republicans didnโt come through for them but that Democrats voted in unusually high numbers for a midterm election. The blame here seems not on lethargic Republican voters โ they werenโt โ but on one particular Republican: President Donald Trump, who inspired Democrats to vote at a historic level for a midterm.
Letโs zero in for a closer look at that phenomenon.
Democrats voted at near-presidential levels. Republicans voted at more normal levels.
There is always some imbalance in turnout; one party is almost always more energized than the other.
The difference this year is the extraordinary size of the imbalance. To understand that, I compared each of the congressional candidatesโ votes this year to their partyโs presidential vote in 2024. In other words, how much of the Kamala Harris vote did Democrats retain; how much of the Donald Trump vote did Republicans retain?
Letโs start with the Democrats.
What we see on the Democratic map is that in most places โ Southside and the counties between Interstate 95 and the Chesapeake Bay are the exceptions โ the Democratic candidates retained more than 90% of the Harris vote. In three localities, the Democratic congressional candidates exceeded the Harris tally: Taylor in Williamsburg, Macy in Harrisonburg, Joy Powers in Dickenson County. Elsewhere, we see some remarkable performances. In Goochland County and Smyth County, Perriello and Powers hit 99.3% of the Harris mark. The amount of campaign funding seems to have had nothing to do with this. Perriello was well-funded, and he apparently used that money well โ Charlottesville hit 98.7% of its Democratic presidential vote, Albemarle County hit 97.1%. Powers, though, had very little to work with, resource-wise, and you can see on the map how she nearly matched the Harris vote in multiple counties. Granted, the Harris vote in those Southwest localities was small, but Powersโ performance was, percentage-wise, right in line with other Democratic congressional candidates in Virginia.
Eugene Vindman (7th): 96.4%
James Walkinshaw (11th): 93.8%
Suhas Subramanyam (10th): 93.7%
Beth Macy (6th): 93.4%
Shannon Taylor (1st): 93.4%
Tom Perriello (5th): 93.0%
Jennifer McClellan (4th): 91.8%
Joy Powers (9th): 91.8%
Don Beyer (8th): 90.9%
Elaine Luria (2nd): 89.9%
Bobby Scott (3rd): 87.4%
Thereโs simply no other way to describe this kind of retention rate: These are insane numbers.
Itโs difficult to make comparisons with previous elections because congressional districts have changed over the years, but we can easily do so at the local level. In 2022, the Democratic candidate for the 6th District seat retained 57.8% of the Democratic presidential vote in Roanoke from 2020. This year, Macy retained 89.8% of the presidential vote in Roanoke, and that was actually at the lower end of retention rates. In 2022, the Democratic candidate in the 6th District retained 59.2% of the Democratic presidential vote in Harrisonburg; Macy exceeded it at 104.4%.
In the 5th District, we see similar improvement. In 2022, the Democratic candidate retained 53.0% of the Democratic presidential vote in Danville from 2020. This year, Perriello improved that to 86.9%. Likewise, Perriello took a 78.7% retention rate in Albemarle County to 97.1% and a 75.2% retention rate in Goochland County to 99.3%.
Before the Trump era, turnout in midterms in Virginia was often in the 40% range. The Trump era increased interest in politics โ itโs polarized them, too, but basic interest is up, as measured through voter turnout. Unfortunately for Republicans, whatโs happened is that Trump has motivated Democrats to vote at unheard-of levels. In Virginia, what Republicans need is for Trump to pass from the scene in hopes that Democratic motivation will recede enough to allow Republicans to win. Case in point: the 2021 governorโs race. With Trump out of office, Republicans were able to sweep the races for governor, lieutenant governor and attorney general and win control of the House of Delegates. Once Trump returned to office, Democrats have flocked back to the voting booth at levels far above normal for those off-year elections.
Now letโs look at the Republican side of the ledger:
What this map shows is that every Republican incumbent facing a well-funded challenger retained 70% or more of the Trump vote from two years ago. Those are strong performances; the problem for Wittman and Kiggans is that the Democrats they were running against had stronger performances at retaining their vote. McGuire and Cline survived because there simply werenโt enough Democrats in their districts for their opponents to pull from; Wittman and Kiggans werenโt so lucky.
Here are the retention rates for each Republican congressional candidate:
Rob Wittman (1st): 79.7%
John McGuire (5th): 74.8%
Jen Kiggans (2nd): 74.4%
Ben Cline (6th): 70.1%
Morgan Griffith (9th): 66.9%
Dave Beckwith (10th): 65.5%
Robert Murray Jr. (4th): 64.9%
Doug Ollivant (7th): 63.7%
Arthur Purves (11th): 63.5%
Tony Sabio (8th): 62.5%
Edwin Rivera Jr. (3rd): 59.1%
These retention rates are generally in line with previous midterms, although there are some local deviations that benefited Republicans. In 2022, the Republican candidate for Congress retained 73.1% of the Republican presidential vote in Lynchburg from 2020. This year, McGuire retained 76.5%. Not a big difference, but every vote matters, especially in a close race. In all, McGuire polled more votes out of Lynchburg than his predecessor, Bob Good, did, and that accounted for about half his winning margin. Thereโs been a lot of chatter about the 5th District race in national circles, particularly on the left, wondering how Perriello could have lost in such a good Democratic year. The consensus there is that Perriello underperformed. These numbers lead me to the opposite conclusion: Perriello didnโt underperform; he squeezed out virtually every Democratic vote that could be found in the district. Perriello lost because McGuire overperformed (likely because Republicans realized that seat was in jeopardy and responded, rather than getting caught by surprise as they were in some districts out of state).
The county that had the lowest Trump vote retention rate was Buchanan County, where Griffith took 54.7% of what Trump won two years ago. However, thatโs an improvement over the last midterms, when Griffith took 47.7% of Trumpโs vote in the previous presidential election. This seems remarkable because Griffith, unlike McGuire, was never in jeopardy. For a non-competitive race, Griffith did a good job of converting presidential-year voters into midterm voters even though there really wasnโt much at stake in that district.
Now letโs move on to some other observations from this data.
Republicans had a Northern Virginia problem and a Southwest Virginia problem
The softness in the Republican turnout was confined to places where it didnโt matter: Those Northern Virginia districts were unwinnable, and the 9th District in Southwest was unloseable. Since the numbers canโt speak, I can only guess at what theyโre saying. Was the retention rate in both places lower because voters understood there wasnโt much at stake? Thatโs certainly possible, but voters there could still have influenced the outcome of three constitutional amendments that Republicans, in general, felt strongly about. Did Trumpโs federal cuts depress the Republican turnout in Northern Virginia? Thatโs certainly possible, too, but that doesnโt explain the Southwest Virginia numbers. However, turnout in Southwest is almost always lower than elsewhere, so this may simply be a reflection of that. Where Republican candidates needed votes, though, they got them โ Wittman and Kiggans lost simply because Democrats turned out at presidential levels while Republicans turned out at congressional levels. The adage applies: They brought a knife to a gunfight.
Democrats had a Southside problem

Notice in the Democratic map how the retention rates fall in Southside. Theyโre still high โ in the 80% to 89% range โ but noticeably lower than those near-100% figures elsewhere. This softness falls mostly in the 5th District but isnโt confined there. It ranges from Henry County in the west (in the 9th District) to Surry, Sussex and Southampton counties in the east (in the 4th District, with part of Southampton also in the 2nd). Thereโs no mathematical explanation for this, so this is speculative, but all these are mostly rural areas with large Black populations. Did the Democratic message not connect as well with rural Black voters? The math is silent, but clearly something was going on.
We also see another patch of softness in the rural counties in the 1st District, which also have significant Black populations. All I know is the math: If a locality with a higher-than-average Black population was rural or a small city, the Democratic retention rate tended to be lower. If it was urban, its retention rate was more in line with Democratic voters elsewhere. Case in point: Richmond and Martinsville have similar population profiles. In both cities, Black residents account for almost half the population. However, the Democratic retention rate in Richmond was 94.4%; in Martinsville, it was 79%.
Could Perriello have won with a stronger performance in Southside?
Those lower retention rates in Southside raise an obvious question: If Perriello had performed there at the same level he did elsewhere in the district, could he have won? Probably not.
I did the math: If Perriello had retained 95% of the Harris vote in those Southside counties rather than the figures below 90% that he got, heโd have still lost โ just by a smaller amount. While those counties take up a lot of space on a map, their populations are small, so the number of votes available is small. This underscores the point: Geography doesnโt vote. People do. There just werenโt enough people there for Perriello.
Even if Perriello had retained at least 95% of the Harris vote in every locality in the district, heโd have still lost. He did exceed that mark in some places. What he needed was a base of 95% everywhere โ plus that excess. Even then, by my math, heโd have won by just 415 votes. So, yes, it was possible for Perriello to win, but in practical terms, that kind of performance is unrealistic. Perriello did an amazing job producing the votes he got, but in the end, he simply ran out of places to get those votes. He needed a more normal turnout from Republicans, but Republicans in the 5th came through with a better performance than Democrats could withstand.
That brings us to this:
Democrats nearly maxed out their vote, but three of them still lost to Republicans

The three westernmost Democrats โ Perriello in the 5th, Macy in the 6th, Powers in the 9th โ performed in ways that were difficult to predict. Statistically speaking, they got almost every Democratic presidential voter in 2024 to come back to the polls in a midterm. That never happens but did this time. They ran as well as anyone could expect, but they still lost because in those rural-based districts, that simply wasnโt enough. Democrats will not win there until they figure out how to persuade Republicans to vote with them. While there are individual instances of that out there, in the aggregate this didnโt happen, and itโs the aggregate that decides elections. For Democrats to win in rural areas, they may need to adopt positions that are very out of line with Democrats elsewhere โ and even then itโs unclear whether the Democratic brand is simply so poisonous to rural voters that different positions wouldnโt matter.
Iโll cite a former Richmond bank teller-turned-pop-star for what Iโll call the Pat Benatar Rule: โHit Me With Your Best Shot.โ Democrats hit Republicans with their best shot this year and still couldnโt win in three rural districts.
One final observation:
Wittman ran the best Republican campaign

This isnโt a judgment on his positions or his strategy, simply his performance. He held onto more of the Trump vote than any other Republican congressional candidate in the state. In eight localities, he retained eight of every 10 Trump voters; in Lancaster County, he hit 87.2% of the Republican presidential vote.
What eventually felled him was demographic change, which I addressed in a previous column. The population weight of that district, which we used to think of as a rural district along the rivers leading to the Chesapeake Bay, is now in the Richmond suburbs. In both Henrico County and Chesterfield County, Taylor converted 94% of the Harris voters from 2024. Just as Perriello ran out of Democratic voters in the 5th, Wittman ran out of Republican voters in the 1st.
As for me, I havenโt run out of things to say about these numbers, but you have likely run out of time to read them all today, so Iโll be back tomorrow to squeeze more lessons out of the returns.
If you really want more political news, we have it every Friday in West of the Capital, our weekly political newsletter. Sign up here:

