Amherst County EMS providers participate in active threat training with the county sheriff's office. Courtesy of Amherst County Fire and EMS.

In Amherst County, Fire and EMS Chief Bradley Beam has a simple go-to phrase: โ€œone team.โ€

He uses it to describe the three volunteer fire departments, one paid department and about 120 first responders staffed between them all that serve more than 30,000 residents across 480 square miles of rural Central Virginia. Itโ€™s a phrase thatโ€™s repeated often because itโ€™s a reminder that everyone has the same goal of keeping the community โ€” and firefighters โ€” safe, he said.

Every team needs a playbook. But making one is a task easier said than done, especially as the fire service statewide faces challenges with limited funding, rising costs, insufficient staffing and evolving response needs, Beam said.ย ย 

About this story

Volunteer fire departments across our region are the first line of defense during emergencies for many communities, but they continue to grapple with declining volunteerism, inadequate resources and funding, and the changing nature of their work.

Cardinal News is amplifying potential solutions to these problems in a months-long project; check out ourย project page to follow along.

The Virginia Fire Services Board, a governor-appointed policy group, has conducted studies of localitiesโ€™ fire systems for more than 30 years, offering recommendations for improvement free of charge and producing blueprints for leaders like Beam.

Amherstโ€™s state study was conducted in 2023, and since then, the county has implemented consistent safety standards, training initiatives and support services across its emergency response system.ย 

The county is one of dozens of localities that have received guidance in the stateโ€™s ongoing effort to observe what strategies are working across the commonwealth and replicate them. State leaders say the studies arenโ€™t a cure-all, and recommendations require consistent work and funding to implement, but even so, they are crucial for solutions to spread across Virginia.

Studies aim to spread successes found elsewhere

Fire departments across the state are experiencing similar challenges, said John Miller, a member of the Virginia Fire Services Board and the chief of fire and emergency response for the stateโ€™s department of forestry. Common difficulties include keeping up with the rise in EMS calls, recruiting and retaining adequate numbers of volunteers, finding funds to cover increasing apparatus costs and organizing independent departments under countywide standards.ย 

The goal of each study is to offer โ€œinsight into what other localities have done that works well,โ€ so successful adaptations to the changing field can be replicated, he said.ย ย ย 

The Virginia Fire Services Board conducts the studies for localities and their fire and EMS departments. The studies assess strengths and weaknesses within the localityโ€™s emergency response system and offer recommendations for improvement, which are advisory in nature and not legal mandates.ย 

Amherst firefighters gather for a training session. Courtesy of Amherst County Fire and EMS.

Each study team consists of five experts across a โ€œbroad cross section from fire and EMS services in Virginia,โ€ Miller said, including board members, staff from the Virginia Department of Fire Programs, and staff from the stateโ€™s office of EMS.

โ€œI think thatโ€™s the greatest benefit of a fire and rescue study, is by pulling in people with experience in working with other localities that have probably been through similar problems over the same length of time, we can use that opportunity to share lessons learned across the commonwealth,โ€ Miller said.ย 

The studies are comprehensive of many elements of emergency response and include a preliminary review of documents, site visits with local fire departments and government bodies and a public hearing to gather input from community members, according to the study manual. They conclude with a presentation of a final report, with the total study timeline taking about three months. The board accepts applications from localities for studies year-round and can approve four studies each year.

Spencer Willett, government affairs manager for the stateโ€™s department of fire programs, said the board has been conducting the studies for more than 30 years. The patterns that have been observed and strategies that have been tested over that period of time guide recommendations in the final reports, he said, and study team members are always asking, โ€œHow do we tailor that recommendation to actually meet the political, financial and geographic needs of the place that weโ€™re in?โ€

Most recently, studies have been released for Patrick County, Halifax County and Prince Edward County.ย 

The board also offers abbreviated reviews to localities that want advice on a focused area of concern. The initiative is new, and the board has yet to conduct such a review, Willett said. Applications for those small studies are open and accepted year-round, he added.ย 

โ€œMakes us safer every time we go outโ€ย 

The state board conducted a study in Amherst County in 2023, responding to the localityโ€™s request to analyze its fire systemโ€™s organization, budget, training, staffing and other operational elements, according to the final report.ย 

Beam, the fire and EMS chief, described the study process as constructive, rather than interrogatory. Many recommendations felt like a conversation, he said, with experts asking, โ€œHey, have you thought about this? Because weโ€™ve seen this work in other places.โ€

In the three years since, fire and EMS leaders have made numerous improvements to the countyโ€™s system, as guided by the study, Beam said.ย 

Some changes didnโ€™t cost the county a penny, Beam said, such as updating and codifying standard operating guidelines for first responders.ย 

Firefighters run drills at Amherst Countyโ€™s training center. Courtesy of Amherst County Fire and EMS.

The 2023 study identified the guidelines as an area in need of improvement, after interviews with firefighters indicated that guidelines were โ€œnot being followed or enforced,โ€ leaving the county โ€œextremely vulnerable to a firefighter injury or death.โ€ Recommendations included updating and codifying the guidelines to create more accountability for following safety standards.ย 

Beam said his team did just that, and the board of supervisors formalized the guidelines by signing them into county code. An example of a guideline, he said, is that firefighters responding to car accidents must wear a reflective vest while in or near the roadway.ย 

โ€œYou would think thatโ€™s a no-brainer, but until thereโ€™s a [guideline] that says it, and there are chiefs and officers who are enforcing it, it never becomes the culture,โ€ he said. โ€œSo now we all catch ourselves. If somebody gets out and doesnโ€™t have a vest, weโ€™re all reaching to hand them one.โ€

Data from a 2024 report from Virginia Commonwealth Universityโ€™s Center for Public Policy and a 2023 report by a workgroup of various state agencies and fire service stakeholders. Graphic by Laura Kebede-Twumasi.

Other improvements were organizational in nature, Beam said. The study reported that there were some โ€œspecialized calls and incidents that required greater resources than availableโ€ and recommended that the county create specific trained teams for specialized calls to maximize available resources. Amherst now has a countywide specialized team for water rescue, Beam said, with consistent training that โ€œallows us to respond as one unit, even though weโ€™re responding from different departments.โ€ย 

The county also formalized ongoing firefighter training โ€” for both volunteer and career members โ€” with one night dedicated to training every month. Building consistency between the volunteer and paid departments is crucial in ensuring that firefighters from across the county can work together efficiently when theyโ€™re all asked to respond to a call, Beam said.ย 

How to apply

The Virginia Fire Services Board accepts applications for full studies and abbreviated reviews year-round, according to the boardโ€™s study manual.ย 

To apply, localities must submit a self-assessment questionnaire, a scope of study agreement and a request letter with detailed reasoning on why a study is needed. Applications should be submitted to the government affairs division of the stateโ€™s department of fire programs.ย 

Applications are reviewed at the boardโ€™s meetings, which are held once per quarter in February, June, September and December. Studies are completed within a year of approval by the board.

More information on the study process and how to apply for it is available on the boardโ€™s website.ย 

Some improvements have required investments from the county, Beam said, such as the creation of a new position in the paid department to oversee a support services division. The division now operates an in-house pharmacy, which put Amherst โ€œahead of the curveโ€ when federal changes caused Virginia EMS providers to transition away from hospital-stocked emergency medication kits.ย 

To cover some recommendations, the county secured $130,000 in Virginia Department of Fire Program grants for new turnout gear, hoods that protect firefightersโ€™ heads and necks from carcinogens and decontamination equipment that cleans gear of carcinogens. The upgrades help protect firefighters from cancer โ€” the leading health risk facing firefighters due to the chemicals they are exposed to while responding to emergencies, according to the study.ย 

The improvements made since 2023 are difficult to track with numbers, Beam said, but he sees a change in how the county prioritizes consistent expectations for quality service and safety for each of the 8,000 annual calls answered.ย 

โ€œIt makes us safer every time we go out,โ€ he said of the study and the changes made in response to it.ย 

Not a โ€œsilver bulletโ€

Beam credits Amhertโ€™s success with adopting the stateโ€™s recommendations to early momentum from stakeholders. As soon as the final report was presented in 2023, the countyโ€™s board of supervisors scheduled a workshop to dive into the study and determine what recommendations could be adopted first.ย 

โ€œI donโ€™t want to say there werenโ€™t hard conversations, but I think thatโ€™s part of whatโ€™s helped lead us to where we are now โ€” to where weโ€™re completely open with one another and, when thereโ€™s a problem, we work together to fix it,โ€ he said of the tone that the first workshop set for future improvements.ย 

Willett said that change can only happen when stakeholders take action after the study process is complete, because otherwise, โ€œthe reportโ€™s just going to sit on a shelf.โ€

โ€œItโ€™s not a silver bullet,โ€ he said. Communication is key in early planning stages, he added, and study teams recommend that counties establish implementation committees to ensure momentum isnโ€™t lost.ย 

Firefighters respond to a fire at an Amherst County commercial building. Courtesy of Amherst County Fire and EMS.

Having an open-minded attitude is also important, Beam said. Firefighters often follow the mindset of โ€œitโ€™s the way weโ€™ve always done it, or thatโ€™s the way weโ€™ve always known,โ€ he said, but change relies on buy-in that a better solution is out there.ย 

Funding can be a barrier to implementing recommendations, Willett said, especially at the rural volunteer departments that are already struggling to make ends meet. And the lack of firefighters themselves can make improvements difficult, Beam added.ย 

โ€œOur call volumes continue to go up, but our available volunteers go down,โ€ Beam said. โ€œThe study will give you some ideas of how you could recruit and do some retention, but you know you donโ€™t automatically get five volunteers with every study, or five more career folks.โ€

The state board doesnโ€™t have the resources to offer implementation assistance to localities at this time, Willett said. Board members conduct the studies on a volunteer basis and have limited time for follow-up visits, and thereโ€™s no funding available to provide localities grants to help adopt recommendations once reports are released.

Small wins can add up

Some consulting companies offer implementation support, said Chris Gannon, the CEO of Gannon Emergency Solutions USA. Heโ€™s worked with emergency response providers in more than 40 countries around the world to study challenges and execute strategies to solve them, including in Pulaski County and other Virginia localities.

Itโ€™s a common saying that stakeholders in the volunteer fire service hate two things: โ€œchange and the way things are,โ€ Gannon said. In his consulting work, he emphasizes that the importance of volunteers isnโ€™t changing, but the model that supports them can, he said in an interview.ย 

Miller said the stateโ€™s studies rarely recommend sweeping changes, and rather focus on what a locality can accomplish with the resources and organization they already have.ย 

Amherst Countyโ€™s water rescue team, which consists of firefighters from departments across the county, trained with other first responders from across the state this summer. Courtesy of Amherst County Fire and EMS.

โ€œThe wins are oftentimes small,โ€ he said. โ€œMaybe something with improved training on a particular level, maybe the suggestion of an improved way of funding. โ€ฆ If they can just do a lot of these little things to medium difficulty kind of things, that makes a big difference.โ€

Gannon said there are many ways to work within the volunteer fire service model to make it more sustainable, such as implementing community paramedicine programs to cut down the number of emergency EMS calls or establishing stronger communication channels between independent departments to leverage group bargaining power for big equipment purchases. Gannon helped implement such changes in Pulaski County in recent years.ย 

โ€œPulaski has proven that taking a different approach can result in improvements using existing resources. The industry needs change and needs to start with the advice being given and challenging the status quo. There are better models of first response that give the citizen and taxpayer improved service for less cost, and neither pride or tradition should stand in the way of accepting that,โ€ he wrote in an email to Cardinal News.ย 

Emma Malinak is a reporter for Cardinal News and a corps member for Report for America. Reach her at...