A Botetourt County judge seemed ready on Monday afternoon to rule that the county’s board of supervisors had violated the state Freedom of Information Act on the day it approved an agreement for a Google data center.
But at least one argument stopped the judge and delayed his decision, likely until next week.
Substitute Circuit Judge Michael Doucette sat for more than five hours as lawyers argued and gathered testimony in a case that retired doctor Robert Dallas filed against Botetourt County, its board of supervisors, its economic development authority and data center developer Helio Capital LLC, an arm of Google.
[Disclosure: Google is one of our donors through its Google News Initiative, which helped support our expansion in the New River Valley. Donors have no say in news decisions; see our policy.]
It focused largely on a nearly day-long June 24, 2025, board meeting that included a portion closed to the public and one late recess, during which an unidentified number of observers left the council chambers and a new group, including regional dignitaries, entered. Dallas’ lawyer played a video for the court, showing portions of the meeting.
The video showed that after the board’s closed meeting early in the day, the board cast public votes on newly added items that hadn’t been part of the published meeting agenda. One of the new items was a performance agreement that passed unanimously, but no one at that time announced what it was for.
About three hours later, after an early-evening recess, then-board Chairwoman Amy White introduced herself to the audience and called on then-Supervisor Steve Clinton, who announced the Google data center deal, which would place a campus at the county’s only industrial park, Botetourt Center at Greenfield.
After Clinton, County Administrator Gary Larrowe spoke and gave a PowerPoint presentation about the deal. Sen. Chris Head, R-Botetourt County; Roanoke Regional Partnership CEO John Hull; and Landon Howard, president of Virginia’s Blue Ridge, the region’s tourism agency, were among the speakers who followed.
The Virginia Freedom of Information Act says that a board must tell the public what it voted on during the meeting. The county’s lawyer, Julian Harf, said that the board did so, in detail, but a few hours after the vote.
Doucette wondered, however, “Was it the same meeting?” The retired Nelson County judge and former Lynchburg prosecutor said that he has observed General Assembly sessions in which groups cycled in and out after a recess, with each receiving different information. He was not sure that the early crowd in Botetourt was the same one that later heard the data center announcement.
He noted that after a recess of at least 15 minutes, White introduced herself “after having chaired the meeting for three and a half hours,” Doucette said.
Harf, who was delivering his closing argument, said that fact wasn’t relevant.
“Oh yes, it is,” Doucette replied.
Larrowe, speaking after White and Clinton at the 2025 announcement, said, “I look up here, and it’s a room full of friends.” Doucette said he wondered why it seemed as if Larrowe was commenting on a new group of people.
“You’re telling me Sen. Head sat there for four hours,” Doucette said.
“Your definition of the same meeting and my definition of the same meeting might not be the same,” the judge added.
Helio’s lawyer, Graham Bryant, followed Haft with his own closing. Doucette asked Bryant: If he rules against Botetourt County, would Google sue the county for breach of contract? Bryant declined to speculate.
Bryant said that the company he represents is not a public body and therefore cannot violate open hearings and open records laws. If Dallas were to get the remedies he asks for, including rescinding the performance agreement, it would affect Google, which has paid money to the county already and started work on the site, Bryant said.
The company has done so “in reliance of that contract,” Bryant said.
With that, Doucette decided to take the case under advisement. He said he would review a case that Bryant cited and ordered a transcript of closing arguments, including that of Dallas’ attorney, John Fishwick. He requested that each party submit one more brief apiece.
“I have a fundamental disagreement” with the county’s argument about that meeting, he said.
Doucette said that time will be tight, with a family trip out of state and the Thanksgiving holiday ahead, but he would work to deliver a judgment on the case, possibly by Monday.
“This will be a hot topic priority for me,” the judge said.

