Councilor Julian Mei (far left) walks away following a tense exchange with Mayor L.C. Jones.
As the Martinsville City Council takes a five-minute recess, council member Julian Mei (far left) walks away following a tense exchange with Mayor L.C. Jones in this photo from January. Cardinal News file image.

The Virginia State Police, the special prosecutor and a retired Roanoke commonwealthโ€™s attorney will meet in December to discuss potential crimes and potentially convening a special grand jury in the Martinsville investigation that encompasses the entire city government.

Gray Collins, the special prosecutor, said he doesnโ€™t know how many people could be charged yet, just that โ€œright now, itโ€™s open to anyone and everyone who mismanaged the funds.โ€

The investigation includes allegations that the city detailed in a press release and said prompted the firing of former City Manager Aretha Ferrell-Benavides. Itโ€™s also closely tied to a recall petition, where residents sought to remove Mayor L.C. Jones from council, said city Commonwealthโ€™s Attorney Patrick Flinn earlier this year.ย 

The investigation continues on, with a forensic auditor reviewing the Sands Anderson workplace probe, as investigators conduct more interviews and meet to discuss the next steps. The city asked for the workplace investigation, which was conducted by Sands Anderson, the firm that formerly acted as the city attorney.

โ€œItโ€™s going much slower than I had hoped,โ€ Collins said of the investigation, mostly due to a lack of staff. The state police is understaffed by as much as 200 positions, he said, and Collinsโ€™ office has previously been down three attorneys, too, he said. Collins is the Colonial Heights commonwealthโ€™s attorney and the third special prosecutor to be appointed to this case.

The lack of staff also has delayed getting a forensic accountant on the case, which Collins requested about six months ago.

Within the last month, the state police assigned Susan Armstrong, a first sergeant, to review the Sands Anderson workplace investigation report, Collins said, โ€œwhich is awesome, because now we finally got someone working on it.โ€

Collins said Don Caldwell โ€” Roanokeโ€™s longtime commonwealthโ€™s attorney before retiring as of the first of this year โ€” is also helping out on the case. Caldwell, who served in the Roanoke post for nearly 50 years, is known for his hands-on, detail-oriented approach.

Caldwell did not respond to a request for comment Thursday.

About the December meeting, Collins said โ€œthat would be โ€ฆ when we would see if weโ€™re going to do the special grand jury, and then we go from there. Because Iโ€™ve got to get the forensic auditor to basically tell me, โ€˜hey, this is where the crimes are,โ€™ then get the documents, and then convene the special grand jury.โ€

While a final decision has not been made, Collins said a special grand jury will likely be called to hear the evidence due to the complexity of the case involving financial records.

โ€œItโ€™d probably be easier for them to understand all that, subpoena the records, and look at it versus a regular grand jury,โ€ Collins said.

The state police investigation goes at least as far back as the Sands Anderson workplace investigation report, Collins said, which started months ago. Collins said he plans to meet with Special Agent Billy McCraw to figure out if they need to go farther back.

Collins said he hopes there will be more interviews.

Jones, the mayor who was suspended and then reinstated earlier this year, still has not interviewed with the state police. Other council members Kathy Lawson, Julian Mei and Aaron Rawls have all interviewed, they each confirmed in October. Rayshaun Gravely did not respond to a request for comment.

McCraw has tried to talk with Jones several times, Collins said, but nothing has been arranged. Jones has maintained heโ€™s done nothing wrong.

Jones recently lost reelection, coming in third in a five-way race for two seats behind two candidates who were backed by the petitioners who sought to remove him earlier this year. That case was dismissed due to an inadequate number of signatures.

With the investigation ongoing, the city recently hired a new full-time chief financial officer, Donna Hall.ย 

Kendall Davis, the cityโ€™s public information officer, said the city would not grant Cardinal News an interview with Hall at this point to talk about her new job.

Hall has 25 years of experience in accounting, auditing, budgeting and financial reporting, Davis said. Hall most recently served as an internal auditor for Piedmont Community Services and managed financial records, annual audits and account reconciliations.

The city did not respond to a request made Wednesday by Cardinal News for Hallโ€™s salary.

Linda Conover, who has been working as the cityโ€™s part-time finance analyst, will continue to work for the city, said City Manager Rob Fincher. Conover was once the cityโ€™s finance director, he said.

The most recent chief financial officer, Richard Stanfield, originally asked Conover to come assist in the finance department because of her institutional knowledge, Fincher said.

โ€œSheโ€™s been just such a big help and sheโ€™s agreed to stay on part-time to kind of help with this transition,โ€ Fincher said. โ€œItโ€™s going to help things a lot by keeping [Conover] here to help get us through, if nothing else, the budget time period.โ€