Trey Adkins. Photo by Lakin Keene.

In February, the Buchanan County Board of Supervisors gave $3.4 million to the Appalachian School of Law because supervisors were concerned that the independent law school based in Grundy might fold under the weight of financial challenges.

Now, in November, the supervisors want that money back. They contend the school is not in a precarious condition, after all. The law school disputes this.

The county board and the private law school, one of the signature assets in the county, are now at odds.

What makes the situation more unusual is that one person serves on both boards. Trey Adkins is an elected member of the board of supervisors; heโ€™s also a member of the law school board โ€” appointed by the board of supervisors to one of the seats that the county is allowed to fill on ASLโ€™s governing body.

Adkins is not a passive member, either. In February, he made the motion on the board of supervisors for the county to give the money to the law school. In November, heโ€™s the one who led the charge for the county to ask for the money back. โ€œCircumstances have changed,โ€ Adkins told the supervisors on Nov. 2. โ€œThereโ€™s been reckless spending. So I look forward to asking for the money back.โ€

This brings up a question: If Adkins is on both boards, and the supervisors and the law school are now in conflict, does he have a conflict of interest? If the law school leadership believes the countyโ€™s grant was necessary for survival, and Adkins, in his role as a county supervisor, now wants that money back, is he acting against the interest of the law school on whose board he serves?

Adkins did not respond to an inquiry. Jerry Kilgore, the former state attorney general who serves as chair of the ASL board, declined to respond.

However, the two state legislators who wrote the most recent revision of Virginiaโ€™s law dealing with nonprofits say that Adkins has a conflict in his dual roles as a county supervisor and a law school board member. A legal expert on nonprofits who serves on a national committee dealing with nonprofit governance agrees. And so does a vast body of law dealing with the legal duties of nonprofit board members.

Does Adkins hold two โ€˜incompatible officesโ€™?

A sign welcomes students back to the Appalachian School of Law in August 2026. Photo by Meghan Mangrum.

There are at least three legal doctrines at play here.

One is the common law โ€œdoctrine of incompatible offices,โ€ which holds that someone canโ€™t simultaneously hold two offices that are in conflict with each other. That doctrine generally deals with offices that are inherently in conflict. For instance, a judge cannot also serve as a police officer โ€” because itโ€™s the duty of the police officer to gather evidence and the duty of the judge to rule on that evidence.

It is unclear whether the positions of county supervisor and a county-appointed member of the law school board are inherently in conflict. Other supervisors before Adkins have been appointed to the law school board. However, the county board and the law school also werenโ€™t in conflict then. On the contrary, they appear to have been in harmony until the past year. Thatโ€™s when the schoolโ€™s long-running financial problems came to the fore. Itโ€™s lost money for 10 of the past 11 years, according to tax records, and has never come close to the 300 students the school says it needs to be financially healthy. Last year, it had 184 students.

Roanoke College offered to take over the school and move it to Salem; that fell through. Buchanan County supervisors appoint nearly half the members on the ASL board; that was part of the deal that located the school in Grundy in 1994. It also makes for an unusual arrangement โ€” appointees of a local government having a significant say in the running of a private school. The countyโ€™s appointees to the law school board were never going to allow the school to be moved out of the county. Now ASL is exploring a possible merger with the University of Pikeville, a private, four-year school just across the line in Kentucky. Pikeville has pledged to keep the school in Grundy, but some supervisors โ€” again, led by Adkins โ€” are skeptical. Adkins has said any merger needs to be โ€œstructured properly.โ€ He has said his idea of that means the supervisors retain some control over the ASL.

That is where Adkinsโ€™ role as a supervisor potentially comes into conflict with his position as an ASL board member. Itโ€™s a perfectly valid position for Adkins, as a county supervisor, to contend the county should retain some control. But what if thatโ€™s not the best position for the school? Itโ€™s obviously debatable what is best for the school, but Adkinsโ€™ position does seem to suggest heโ€™s prioritizing his outlook as county supervisor over his other role. Perhaps he should โ€” he was, after all, elected supervisor and appointed to the ASL board. However, Adkinsโ€™ insistence that the school return the countyโ€™s $3.4 million donation more clearly puts him at odds with the schoolโ€™s interest. Getting that $3.4 million back might well be in the best interest of Buchanan County; thatโ€™s a political judgment. However, itโ€™s hard to see how making a financially struggling school return $3.4 million can be in the schoolโ€™s best interest.ย 

This is where we come to the other two legal doctrines at issue, both of which are considered a form of fiduciary duty.

The law requires a โ€˜duty of careโ€™ and a โ€˜duty of loyaltyโ€™ to a nonprofit board

The Appalachian School of Law in Grundy. Courtesy of the law school.

Independent Sector is a national coalition of nonprofits. Earlier this year it established a 23-member Panel on Sector Independence to offer guidance on how nonprofits may โ€œfreely pursue their missions with robust and effective self-governance.โ€ One of those members is Richard Hackney, a law professor at the University of Pittsburgh who is considered an expert on nonprofit law.

โ€œUnder nonprofit law, officers and directors, which this fellow [Adkins] would be, owe a โ€˜duty of careโ€™ and a โ€˜duty of loyaltyโ€™ to the corporation,โ€ Bagley said in a telephone interview. โ€œThe duty of care is to consider its business as his business. The duty of loyalty is where the conflict is because, as a county supervisor, he has a duty thereโ€ that is now in conflict with Adkinsโ€™ duty of loyalty to the law school board.

The Virginia Society of Certified Public Accountants publishes an eight-page document on โ€œResponsibilities and Risks of Nonprofit Board Membersโ€ that also details the legal standards for โ€œduty of careโ€ and โ€œduty of loyalty.โ€ So does a Washington, D.C., law firm that specializes in nonprofit work. The author of the article, โ€œLegal Duties of Nonprofit Board Members,โ€ is Jeffery Tenenbaum, whose resume describes him as โ€œa frequent author, lecturer, media commentator and expert witness on nonprofit legal matters.โ€ He declined to be interviewed, but his article on the law firm website provides clear guidance (and also mirrors what the Virginia Society of Certified Public Accountants says).

The โ€œduty of careโ€ is โ€œvery broad,โ€ Tenenbaum writes. โ€œOfficers and directors must act in a manner which they believe to be in the best interests of the nonprofit.โ€ Is Adkins acting in the โ€œbest interestsโ€ of ASL when he insists, as a county supervisor, the school give back $3.4 million?

The โ€œduty of loyalty,โ€ however, is much more specific. โ€œThis is a duty of faithfulness to the nonprofit,โ€ Tenebaum writes. โ€œThis means that officers and directors must give undivided allegiance to the nonprofit when making decisions affecting the nonprofit.โ€ This is where Adkinsโ€™ dual role seems most questionable since he cannot give โ€œundivided allegianceโ€ to ASL when he also owes allegiance to his role as a county supervisor โ€” and the voters who elected him.

โ€œWhen he votes to return the money, heโ€™s not acting in accordance with his position on the law school board,โ€ Hackney said. โ€œThis does seem to present a classic conflict of interest.โ€ In representing the people of Buchanan County and insisting the school return the money, โ€œheโ€™s not representing the best interest of the school.โ€

Kevin Martingayle is a former president of the Virginia State Bar and a Virginia Beach attorney who specializes in municipal law. โ€œIf youโ€™re a board of supervisors trying to keep control, thatโ€™s the priority. For the law school, the priority needs to be the students. In the academic world, the priority follows the student,โ€ he said in a telephone interview. โ€œI see a conflict. I donโ€™t know if itโ€™s an ethical or legal conflict, but itโ€™s a practical conflictโ€ because the two boards need to be looking out for different constituencies โ€” the supervisors for the county they govern, the law school board for the students theyโ€™re trying to educate. Those priorities may not always align and might even come into conflict, he said.

Martingayle also thinks itโ€™s particularly detrimental to the school for the county to ask for its money back. โ€œTo me, given the fact that the school has come under some close scrutiny by the American Bar Association, that doesnโ€™t make any sense,โ€ Martingayle said. The ABA has long been concerned about the schoolโ€™s meager finances. For the county to try to withdraw that funding invites more scrutiny by the ABA and a possible loss of accreditation, Martingayle said. โ€œThat can send a school into a death spiral,โ€ he said.

On the contrary, he said, somebody โ€” either the school or the county โ€” ought to be investing in student housing for ASL. Students are forced to find their own housing. โ€œWhen youโ€™re living in a remote area, thatโ€™s not a very attractive arrangement,โ€ Martingayle said. โ€œThey need to have some serious housing investment . . . The most glaring problem is you canโ€™t have a commuter school in a community like that.โ€

The details of such potential housing constitute another area where the interests of the county and the interest of the school might be in conflict.

The University of Pikeville. Courtesy of Epling Media.
The University of Pikeville. Courtesy of Epling Media.

The legal experts on nonprofit law I contacted all agreed that Adkins has a conflict, although there was disagreement about how best to resolve it.

At a minimum, Hackney said, Adkins needs to recuse himself on the ASL board from any action dealing with these county funds. To do otherwise โ€œputs him in a conflicted position,โ€ Hackney said.

Senate Majority Leader Scott Surovell, D-Fairfax County, who sponsored the Senate version of the stateโ€™s latest rewrite of nonprofit law, agrees: โ€œHe probably has a personal interest and should recuse. Canโ€™t serve two masters.โ€

Del. Patrick Hope, D-Arlington County, who sponsored the House version of that legislation, sent a longer email in which he suggested someone in Adkinsโ€™ position should recuse himself both from the nonprofit board and the board of supervisors: โ€œWithout taking a formal position, generally, whenever a direct conflict of interest arises and fiduciary duties are in direct opposition, a local official should recuse himself from discussions and votes on both sides of the dispute.โ€

Both Hope and Surovell advised consulting the stateโ€™s conflict of interest law. That law, though, mostly deals with making sure public officials donโ€™t use their office to enrich themselves or their businesses through contracts or other self-dealing. Thatโ€™s not an issue here. Adkins, like other ASL board members, doesnโ€™t get paid for his service there, and no one is suggesting that his position on the county funds benefits him personally. He has simply taken a political position that appears to conflict with his duty to the ASL board. Ultimately, the stateโ€™s conflict of interest law appears to be silent on the matter, although the common law doctrines of incompatible offices and duty of loyalty would seem to apply.

Tenenbaum, in the article posted on his law firmโ€™s website, offers the most extreme remedy: โ€œFor pervasive and continuing conflicts,โ€ he writes, โ€œresignation from the individualโ€™s nonprofit leadership post or from the outside conflicting responsibility may be required.โ€

The conflict between Adkinsโ€™ position as a county supervisor and the law school board seems clear when the issue is simply whether the school should return the county funds. A larger question looms, though: Thereโ€™s potential conflict between the countyโ€™s view on the desirability of an ASL merger with the University of Pikeville and the law schoolโ€™s view. Must Adkins recuse himself from all law school discussions on the proposed merger?

Adkins also faces felony charges

There is another twist to Adkins being on the ASL law school board: his own experience with the legal system as a defendant.

In 2022, Adkins was charged with 87 domestic-related counts; most were charges of stalking and violating an order of protection, which are misdemeanors.

Adkins later pleaded guilty to five counts of violation of a protective order and one count of illegal use of a tracking device. For each count, he was sentenced to 30 days in jail, with 29 days suspended.

The rest of the charges were dismissed.

Also in 2022, a special grand jury indicted Adkins on 82 felony counts related to alleged election fraud: 34 counts of making a false statement, 11 counts of violating absentee voting procedures, 11 counts of forging public records and eight counts of embezzling public money. The embezzlement charges were later nolle prossed, meaning the prosecution didnโ€™t proceed on those charges. Adkins is still awaiting trial on the other charges.

Meanwhile, a special prosecutor has been appointed to investigate an unnamed elected official in Buchanan County; Adkins has said he is the target. Itโ€™s unclear what that investigation is about.

This is an unusual profile for a law school board member. In the General Assembly, state Sen. Louise Lucas, D-Portsmouth, has been indicted on felony charges โ€” and now faces some calls to resign. What should be the standard for a law school board member?ย 

When I recounted this legal history, Hackney, the University of Pittsburgh law professor who deals with nonprofits, was succinct about Adkins: โ€œHe shouldnโ€™t be on the board.โ€

Yancey is founding editor of Cardinal News. His opinions are his own. You can reach him at dwayne@cardinalnews.org...