Lynchburg Vice Mayor Curt Diemer is accused of using a fake social media account to praise himself and some colleagues while criticizing others, after photos of him appeared on an account with a different name in late October.

Since then, Indivisible Lynchburg, the local chapter of a nationwide progressive movement, issued an open letter calling for increased online transparency from city council members.ย 

โ€œResidents deserve to know who is behind the accounts shaping conversations about their city,โ€ the open letter said.

Diemer has not yet responded to Indivisible Lynchburg, said one of its leaders, Jen Staton. Diemer, who was elected as the Ward III representative on council in 2024, also declined to comment to Cardinal News.ย 

This isnโ€™t the first time residents are speaking up about city council membersโ€™ social media use. In early October, a city resident called some of Marty Misjunsโ€™ social media posts โ€œhate speechโ€ and went viral for it. In March, residents criticized Diemer for a Facebook comment that compared Virginiaโ€™s redistricting effort to rape.

Meanwhile, power is shifting on the dais, as three Republican incumbents prepare to turn their seats over to three incoming Democrats who won the spots this month. Misjuns, Stephanie Reed and Mayor Larry Taylor will be replaced by Christina Delzingaro, Dave Henderson and Nat Marshall come January, after the Democratic slate ran a campaign powered by promises of civility and professionalism.ย 

Council members Marty Misjuns, left, and Curt Diemer, right. Photo by Emma Malinak.

Now, residents are left to ask, โ€œWhere do we need to go from here?โ€ said Beth White, a resident who spoke against Diemerโ€™s comments in March and continues to be concerned about what she sees as unethical uses of social media.ย 

A closer look at the Jordan Jones account

Last month, a Facebook account under the name Jordan Jones posted photos of Diemer at a Rush concert in Washington, D.C. The post included a label that showed the photos were taken with Ray-Ban Meta smart glasses, which Diemer appeared to be wearing at the concert.ย 

Diemer regularly posts on a โ€œCurt Diemer for Lynchburg City Councilโ€ Facebook account. Recent photos and videos posted there also have the โ€œRay-Ban Meta glassesโ€ tag.ย 

On his personal Instagram account, with the username โ€œcdiemer,โ€ the council member posted a story with a picture of himself at the concert with the Rush song โ€œThe Treesโ€ playing in the background. The same photo and background music were posted on the Jones account, according to screenshots provided by council member Chris Faraldi.ย 

The Jones account is private, so posts reviewed by Cardinal News have been provided via screenshots. Comments on public pages were accessed on Facebook.ย 

Faraldi wrote in a Facebook post on Oct. 26 and in a press release on Oct. 28 that the concert photos exposed the Jones account as Diemerโ€™s โ€œburner account,โ€ or a secondary profile created to conceal a userโ€™s identity and maintain anonymity.ย 

At a city council meeting on Oct. 27, some members referred to Diemer as Jones. As part of that, Faraldi said, โ€œThank you, Jordan,โ€ to Diemer, and Diemer began a sentence with โ€œJordan agreesโ€ and another sentence with โ€œJordan wantsโ€ when speaking about a motion he seconded. The exchanges were met with chuckles on the dais and in the audience.ย 

The Jones account has posted more than 200 comments on city council meeting livestream videos on the cityโ€™s Facebook page since 2025, according to documents and screenshots Faraldi provided. Jones also made comments on other Facebook pages, including Faraldiโ€™s, where local government topics are discussed.ย 

Faraldi described the Jones comments as โ€œoutlandish,โ€ โ€œaggressiveโ€ and โ€œhatefulโ€ in a press release.

Several comments posted by Jones are critical of Faraldi, Reed and Taylor โ€” the three Republicans often seen on one side of a GOP divide, opposite Diemer, Misjuns and council member Jacqueline Timmer.ย 

Recent Jones comments on city council meeting livestream videos called Faraldi โ€œChaos Chrisโ€ and โ€œthe head clown in this circus.โ€ One from June 2025 said, about Faraldi, โ€œI think he is trying to provoke Marty into punching him in the face. I know I would for that comment.โ€

โ€œNot surprisingly, it is the more incendiary kind of comments that are going to get eyeballs,โ€ said Bethany Teachman, a psychology professor at the University of Virginia and the co-director of Thriving Youth in a Digital Environment, a research group at the school. Some research suggests that outgroup hostility, in other words, saying something negative about an opponent or about others, is the single strongest predictor of a social media post being shared, she added. Itโ€™s the process that helps to fuel polarization.ย 

โ€œSo itโ€™s not even just about negative language. Itโ€™s particularly about incivility or hostility towards someone who is not agreeing with your side,โ€ she said. โ€œItโ€™s not a big stretch to see how that is very quickly going to lead to escalation โ€” that being sent to more and more people like you, who then become more and more of an in group who is against the out group.

โ€œIf one person posts something that is uncivil or hostile, itโ€™s much more likely to get that same kind of reaction back, so you get this very unfortunate cycle thatโ€™s happening where things can escalate very quickly,โ€ Teachman said.ย 

The Jones account also praised Diemer, Misjuns and Timmer in comments and posts. โ€œI didnโ€™t detect a hatefull (sic) bone in Mr. Diemerโ€™s body,โ€ one comment said. One post, describing Misjuns, said, โ€œThis guy would make a great Mayor. He is a true servant of the people.โ€ One comment about Timmer called her โ€œa great representative for us in Ward I.โ€

Jones also wrote about Ward II when he posted about the recent water service outage at Park Place Apartments. His post said, โ€œMisjuns was helping our entire apartment complex get emergency water so we could flush our toilets and have something to drink in the middle of the event. Thank you sir. Weโ€™ve been without water for 4 days and you and the volunteers made it better!โ€

Faraldi said he found that post to be one of the most alarming.

โ€œItโ€™s one thing to have hidden political attacks. If thatโ€™s the way you think you need to get your point across, and you canโ€™t own it yourself, by all means, go for it,โ€ Faraldi said in a phone interview. โ€œI think it crosses a line when youโ€™re pretending to live at an apartment complex and say youโ€™ve been out of water for a number of days as if you live there and you donโ€™t.โ€ย 

The Jones account remained active after doubts about its owner spread. Taylor posted on Oct. 28 a criticism of Diemerโ€™s alleged use of the Jones account. The Jones account responded to the post. In subsequent replies, the Curt Diemer for Lynchburg City Council account engaged in the conversation, too.ย 

More than an isolated incident

White, the resident who spoke against Diemerโ€™s comments in March, said itโ€™s hard to measure how big of a reach the Jones account has. She said she recalls seeing comments from the account โ€œanywhere, as far as city council things were concernedโ€ and knows the account replied to and conversed with numerous residents in comment sections.

โ€œItโ€™s fine if you want to have multiple Facebook pages. Thatโ€™s your business. But when you are a public official, especially one who talks very loudly all the time about the need for transparency and the need for things to be done aboveboard, then at the same time, youโ€™re creating fake social media profiles, pretending to be someone that youโ€™re not โ€” thereโ€™s a problem with that,โ€ White said.ย 

Sheโ€™s especially concerned about the Jones posts relating to Diemerโ€™s March Facebook comment about the redistricting referendum, White said. The Jones account defended Diemer, with comments such as โ€œI still think his analogy wasnโ€™t strong enough,โ€ on the livestream video of the city council meeting at which the rape comparison was discussed.

White said sheโ€™s noticed a rising temperature on social media for years, with comments like those from elected officials.

A post on the Jordan Jones Facebook account includes photos of Vice Mayor Curt Diemer. Screenshot courtesy of Chris Faraldi.

Many see a similar pattern, said Megan Duncan, an associate professor at Virginia Techโ€™s School of Communication who researches social media and politics.ย 

Duncan said social media culture among politicians has changed significantly in the past two decades. The first social media accounts associated with politicians were often run by communications professionals, not the politicians themselves, and were mainly treated as a one-way platform to distribute information from the politician to the public.

โ€œTweeting back at President Obama in 2010 was just as effective as screaming at your television when a play doesnโ€™t go well in a football game,โ€ Duncan said.ย 

More recently, Duncan said, thereโ€™s been a deprofessionalization of the way politicians treat social media and the start of an โ€œera where we see a lot of politicians using their social media to cultivate a culture.โ€ That online community can be healthy for democracy because there is more two-way communication between leaders and their constituents and among constituents who are engaging in conversations about governance, Duncan said.ย 

โ€œHaving more people be willing to speak up, even when their opinion is in the minority, is awesome in most cases,โ€ she said. โ€œIt just risks people seeing only extreme and salient opinions from the people on the polar opposites.โ€ย 

Itโ€™s important to remember that the extremes that are amplified on social media are not representative of all public opinion, Duncan said. Research has shown that most people with moderate opinions are not participating in online commenting around politics, so the posts you see are from people with the extreme attitudes and high political salience.

Regardless, Duncan said, social media is teaching residents more about their local politicians than they ever used to have access to.

โ€œWhen youโ€™re talking about garbage service and local water utilities, things that are playing out on a national level arenโ€™t going to be typical topics of conversationโ€ at a city council meeting, she said. Social media posts show โ€œa lot more information that theyโ€™re not going to put on a yard sign.โ€ย 

Outcome of the open letter

On Oct. 30, Indivisible Lynchburg posted an open letter to Lynchburg City Council members and candidates, asking them to disclose all social media accounts they own, operate or moderate in any way, including accounts maintained under pseudonyms or for groups.ย 

โ€œRecent revelations that a sitting City Council member used an alternate social media profile to comment on city business and engage with residents without disclosing their identity have raised some important questions about transparency and public trust,โ€ the open letter said. โ€œResidents should be able to know who they are engaging with, particularly when conversations involve city government, public policy, and decisions that affect our community. Using an alternate identity to participate in those conversations without disclosing a connection to elected office can mislead residents and undermine trust in the public process.โ€

Of the seven city council members that will be on the dais come January, Indivisible Lynchburg has received responses from all of them except Timmer and Diemer, Staton said. The members and members-elect โ€œexplained that they maintain personal and campaign profiles and that any administrative access they have to other pages or profiles is related to their professional responsibilities,โ€ she said.

Council members Marty Misjuns and Jacqueline Timmer and Vice Mayor Curt Diemer, left to right, appear in March outside Lynchburg Circuit Court. Photo by Emma Malinak.

Timmer provided her response to Cardinal News directly: โ€œI am strongly supportive of transparency and accountability so I donโ€™t mind saying I have no hidden social media accounts,โ€ she wrote. She added that transparency should extend to Indivisible too and the source of its โ€œfunding and training which it appears largely flows from national and international donors.โ€

Staton said the majority of funding for the Lynchburg chapter comes from local donors, and the national organization will rarely provide small grants. Otherwise, the national organization helps with elements such as branding, weekly organizing calls and Zoom training, but local volunteers power Lynchburgโ€™s activities, she said.

Faraldi said the Jones account opened many residentsโ€™ eyes to a โ€œvery disingenuous way to engage in the political realm,โ€ and added that heโ€™s considering working with the city council to draft a code of conduct to better guide how council members engage with each other and residents.ย 

โ€œOne of the things I like to do when I talk about impacts of social media is to recognize itโ€™s neither all bad nor all good,โ€ said Teachman, the UVa professor. Politicians can use social media as a positive method to increase transparency and share information, and higher citizen engagement online can encourage politicians to take action on issues, she said.ย 

Thereโ€™s hope for more constructive and positive engagement with social media, Teachman said, if people work to build healthier habits. For example, she said, it can help to limit passive scrolling, in which algorithms share targeted content from โ€œa very small slice of the information that is out there.โ€

โ€œInstead of it being that you just are seeing what gets shared with you โ€” that takes you down that rabbit hole of more and more uncivil discourse and more and more extreme opinions โ€” if instead people are intentionally seeking out different sources of information, if they are intentionally choosing what they want to look at, we can really shift how rapidly that negative escalation is happening,โ€ she said.

Emma Malinak is a reporter for Cardinal News and a corps member for Report for America. Reach her at...