Virginia Gov. Abigail Spanberger gets a standing ovation before addressing the joint assembly inside the Virginia State Capitol in Richmond on Jan. 17, 2026. Photo by Bob Brown.
Virginia Gov. Abigail Spanberger gets a standing ovation before addressing the joint assembly inside the Virginia State Capitol in Richmond on Jan. 19, 2026. Photo by Bob Brown.

Virginia Democrats are feeling exhilarated, and well they should be: Theyโ€™ve just reelected a U.S. senator by a landslide margin, flipped two U.S. House seats to win their highest number of representatives in the Virginia delegation since 1964 and passed three constitutional amendments that enshrine some of their most cherished policies.

Now they have their sights set on more: In next yearโ€™s General Assembly elections, they aim to expand their majorities in both the state Senate (now 21-19) and the House of Delegates (now 64-36).

The potential upside is remarkably high. The State Navigate site (run by Virginia Tech grad Chaz Nuttycombe) calculates that eight Republican senators and nine Republican delegates hold seats where Democratic congressional candidates won majorities this year. Based on those numbers, Senate Majority Leader Scott Surovell, D-Fairfax County, is being modest when he declares โ€œ27 in โ€™27.โ€ In theory, Democrats could win 29 Senate seats โ€” and go as high as 73 in the House of Delegates.

Here are the figures for the Senate:

State senatorHome localityDemocratic margin in 2026
Richard Stuart Westmoreland County: +1.3
Christie New Craig Chesapeake +2.0
Bill DeSteph Virginia Beach +11.1
Glen Sturtevant Chesterfield County +15.3
David Suetterlein Roanoke County +16.9
Emily Jordan Isle of Wight County +19.1
Tara Durant Fredericksburg +21.7
Danny Diggs York County +22.1

And the House:

Wendell Walker Lynchburg +2.4
Otto Wachsmann Sussex County +3.5
Buddy FowlerHanover County +3.8
Madison Whittle Danville +6.3
Ann Ferrell TataVirginia Beach +7.8
Joe McNamara Roanoke County +8.0
Mike CherryColonial Heights +8.2
Tony Wilt Rockingham County +8.9
Rob BloxomAccomack County +10.4

At the risk of being a killjoy for Democrats, I must inject a note of caution: All these figures are based on an unusual voting pattern that may be difficult for Democrats to replicate next year.

I laid out the details in Tuesdayโ€™s column: Republicans this year were not lethargic. They voted at normal levels for a midterm election (and in some places voted at a slightly higher level). The reason Democrats did so well is that they voted at near-presidential levels. That enabled Democrats Shannon Taylor and Elaine Luria to oust Republicans Rob Wittman in the 1st District and Jen Kiggans in the 2nd District, and Democrat Tom Perriello to come close to ousting Republican John McGuire in the 5th District.

That imbalance between Democratic and Republican voting levels certainly colored some places blue on the election map that had previously been red. The question for both parties is whether that same imbalance will persist into November 2027. If it does, then, yes, there are lots of Republican legislators in previously safe seats who will find themselves cleaning out their offices. If it doesnโ€™t, then these potential Democratic gains are vastly overstated.

There are, undoubtedly, some Republican incumbents who are vulnerable. Del. Tony Wilt, R-Rockingham County, faces the challenge of a district that is changing demographically. He won last time by just 257 votes. A more concerted push to turn out voters from James Madison University could flip that district to Democrats. Sen. Danny Diggs, D-York County, won last time by just 725 votes. There might be that many new voters in that district anyway. That seems a seat that could go either way in any election year. Likewise, Sen. Tara Durant, R-Fredericksburg, occupies a seat where voters may be realigning โ€” or, perhaps more accurately, population growth is realigning that district toward Democrats.

For Democrats to win some of the other seats, though, theyโ€™d need a repeat of this yearโ€™s turnout pattern. That is certainly possible. President Donald Trump will still be in office, and he has been a unique motivating factor for Democrats. In Virginia, they have won seats every year heโ€™s been in office. Put another way, Trump has been political poison for many Republican legislators in Virginia. Itโ€™s probably no accident that as soon as he was out of office, Republicans in Virginia made a brief comeback to sweep the 2021 statewide elections and win the House of Delegates.

On the other hand, what we just had was a federal election based on federal issues. Next year, weโ€™ll have a state election with a different set of issues. With a Democratic majority in Congress, voter reaction to whatโ€™s happening in Washington might โ€” key word, might โ€” be muted. Republicans this year will clearly be on the defensive, issues-wise, having to defend tariffs, gas prices, the war with Iran. Republicans in Virginia next year might well feel themselves on the offensive, with the administration of Gov. Abigail Spanberger as the main target. The main issue that Democrats might be vulnerable on is the same one that they ran on last year: affordability. This was a powerful argument, but itโ€™s also measurable. Republicans will only need to ask: Is your life more affordable than it was? If not, Republicans will put the blame on Democrats, rightly or wrongly. Some of that will be wrong โ€” Virginia Democrats have no control over tariffs, gas prices and inflation in general. Some of it, though, will be right โ€” Spanberger returned Virginia to the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative. That may have many benefits, but it does result in a charge added to your utility bill.

Both parties will be jockeying to be seen as the party most concerned about, and most equipped to deal with, rising utility bills. Not-so-fun-fact: The energy plan the governor released this fall showed that utility bills will go up no matter what we do. Iโ€™ve made the case before that neither party is particularly well-equipped to deal with energy issues. Republicans will make the case that we should repeal the Clean Economy Act, which mandates renewable energy. If we did, that would result in more use of natural gas. However, as weโ€™ve seen from the controversies around the Mountain Valley Pipeline and gas plants in Chesterfield, Cumberland and Fluvanna counties, nobody wants a gas pipeline or gas plant nearby. Democrats make the case that we need more solar, but their localities arenโ€™t the places where utility-scale solar is likely to go โ€” and rural, Republican-voting counties are now suffering from what one official in Pittsylvania County has called โ€œsolar fatigue.โ€

We have plenty of time to debate all those issues; the point is that just because the 2026 turnout patterns produced some General Assembly that voted Democratic doesnโ€™t mean theyโ€™ll vote that way next year.

You can see the overall turnout patterns on these two maps:

First the Democrats:

Now the Republicans:

With that background, letโ€™s look at some specific districts from Southwest and Southside that turn up on the list of potential Democratic targets. The question with all these is: Can Democrats duplicate that kind of turnout imbalance a second year in a row (and, in some cases, a third year in a row if you count last yearโ€™s governorโ€™s race)? Republicans had a weak candidate for governor last year and all kinds of complications this year with Trump, Iran and the economy, but what will next year hold?

Del. Wendell Walker, R-Lynchburg

House District 52 puts all of Lynchburg in the same district, with a piece of Campbell County to make the numbers work out.

The precincts in this House district went Democratic this year by 2.4 percentage points. To achieve that, Democrats had to mount an extraordinary effort. In Lynchburg, Democrats reached 92.7% of their presidential vote two years ago, while Republicans produced a more normal 76.5%. The question here, and in all these other districts, is: Can they do that again? One potentially complicating factor in this district: Thereโ€™s talk of a primary challenge to Walker, growing out of the bad blood thatโ€™s been flowing for four years in the intraparty fighting among city council Republicans. Would a Republican primary winner โ€” be it Walker or some as-yet-unidentified challenger โ€” be in a weakened position that would make him or her vulnerable in the fall? I suspect Virginia Republicans would love to avoid a primary fight because theyโ€™d want to use that money in the fall to help vulnerable incumbents, but some Lynchburg Republicans might have entirely different motives.

Del. Otto Wachsmann, R-Sussex County

House District 83. Courtesy of Virginia Supreme Court.
House District 83. Courtesy of Virginia Supreme Court.

The precincts in this rural district in eastern Southside went Democratic by 3.5 percentage points this fall. Thatโ€™s because the Democratic retention rate in Isle of Wight County, the most populous locality in the district, was 91% while the Republican retention rate in Isle of Wight ran 78.9%. In other parts of the district, the Democratic retention rate fell into the low 80s while the Republican rate fell into the high 60s.

Del. Madison Whittle, R-Danville

House District 49. Courtesy of Virginia Supreme Court.
House District 49. Courtesy of Virginia Supreme Court.

The precincts in his House district this year went Democratic by 6.3 percentage points. Thatโ€™s because Democrats in Danville won 86.9% of the votes that Kamala Harris won in 2024 while Republicans won only 69.6% of the Donald Trump vote. Danville accounts for about half the voters in the district. The same imbalance continues into other parts of the district. In Pittsylvania, Democrats turned out 87.7% of their presidential vote while Republicans turned out 72.4%. In Halifax County, Democrats turned out 85.5% of their presidential vote while Republicans turned out 72.6% of theirs.

Del. Joe McNamara, R-Roanoke County

House District 40. Courtesy of Virginia Supreme Court.
House District 40. Courtesy of Virginia Supreme Court.

Nearly six of every 10 voters in this district are in Roanoke County, which, given the countyโ€™s Republican tendencies, ought to make this district a lock for a Republican incumbent. It makes the list, though, because in this yearโ€™s election, Democrats in Roanoke County held onto 91.8% of the presidential vote totals while Republicans held onto 71% of theirs. Thatโ€™s quite a respectable figure on the Republican side, but this was an unusual year, and that Democratic tally is beyond impressive. A little more than a quarter of this district is in Salem, which saw similar rates: 89.3% for the Democrats, 67.4% for the Republicans. Then thereโ€™s about 15% of the vote in Roanoke, where Democrats held onto 89.8% of their vote while the Republican retention fell to 61.8%. Thatโ€™s not the lowest Republican retention rate in the state, but it is on the low end. McNamara will want to figure out why that rate was so low and try to reverse it. Not just McNamara, either โ€ฆ

State Sen. David Suetterlein, R-Roanoke County

Senate District 4. Courtesy of Virginia Supreme Court.
Senate District 4. Courtesy of Virginia Supreme Court.

Hereโ€™s the best news for Republicans and maybe not the worst news for Democrats, but certainly not helpful news: McNamaraโ€™s district overlaps with that of Suetterleinโ€™s state Senate district. The two Republican legislators are good friends and longtime political allies. That means there will be two Republicans working the same territory to beef up the Republican turnout next year. Yes, there likely will be two Democrats, too, but itโ€™s not as if Republicans will be caught unawares.

State Sen. Emily Jordan, R-Isle of Wight County

The 17th state Senate District. Courtesy of Virginia Supreme Court.
The 17th state Senate District. Courtesy of Virginia Supreme Court.

This is much the same situation as Suetterleinโ€™s district encompassing McNamaraโ€™s; Jordanโ€™s district also covers Wachsmannโ€™s district, so this means two targeted Republicans working the same turf. Almost half her district is in Suffolk, which this year had a 90.9% Democratic retention rate compared to a 74.8% Republican retention rate.

The Republican retention rate in the rural, westernmost parts of this district was very much on the low side this year: 69.1% in Greensville County, 69.6% in Brunswick County. On the other hand, Democratic retention rates were low there, too โ€” just higher. One thing to keep in mind: Neither side this year had much reason to vote in those counties other than the constitutional amendments. The Senate race was lopsided, and so was the congressional race (the 4th District, represented by Democrat Jennifer McClellan, for many of those counties). Next year, both parties will give voters a reason to turn out.

If Democrats wind up making a serious play for any of these districts, it would represent a serious expansion of our usual election maps in Virginia. With these election numbers now finalized, Republicans now know what theyโ€™re potentially dealing with, and Democrats now know what kind of math would be required to flip these seats.

Yancey is founding editor of Cardinal News. His opinions are his own. You can reach him at dwayne@cardinalnews.org...