Marion Town Hall is pictured, located in Smyth County. Photo by Siena Duncan.

Out of over two dozen far Southwest Virginia towns, only one ousted three incumbents this election cycle. 

Marion residents voted out three of four town council incumbents, who all ran for reelection this November. Marion is Smyth County’s seat and home to about 5,500 people — and experienced some buzz about data center rumors in the months leading up to the election. The challengers who won seats say the local data center questions contributed to the upset, as well as more civic activism from town residents on the whole.

A handful of towns across the region replaced one or two incumbents, but three was the record this year. The last time more than one incumbent lost in Marion was in 2012 — and across 25 years of state election records, this is the first time the town has ousted three at once.

The new Marion council members will be sworn in at the beginning of January. Council members serve for four years, and elections are staggered across seven seats. Four were up for election this year. 

On Marion’s winning slate was Jim Barker, who has served on the council on and off since 2010. Barker, a retired U.S. Forest Service worker, stepped down in 2024 in the middle of a council meeting, citing frustrations with the town manager at the time, Bill Rush. In his retirement letter, he called the council “complicit and malfeasant.”

Rush retired later that year, after over a decade in the position. 

“The power structure on the council has now changed,” Barker said by phone, referring to the election results. “It was pretty much destroyed this election. Citizens can come in and tell us what they think, and we will listen and try to act on it, which is not normally what’s happened in the last two or three years.” 

Barker, who earned about 15% of the vote, has witnessed council members visibly ignore the concerns of residents who speak during town meetings, he said, or even get angry that they’re being critiqued. Overall, the culture on the town council is dismissive toward public input at best and sometimes abusive toward residents at worst, Barker said.

The town began to livestream council meetings on YouTube in early 2025. Now that moments of tension between council members and constituents can be distributed online, people are paying more attention to town government, Barker said.

“There was just a loss of trust,” he said. “I think that’s what really pushed us over.”

Of the incumbents, Suzanne Jennings, Tricia Spencer and Larry Carter all lost their bids to keep their seats, earning about 13%, 12% and 11% of the vote, respectively. None responded to requests for comment.

Jennings has been on the council for 20 years, and Spencer has served for 15 years. Carter served from 2012 to 2024, lost reelection, and then won a seat again during a 2025 special election for two vacant spots. 

Debra Hayes was the sole incumbent who won reelection, winning the largest share of the vote at about 16%. She has been on the council for about a year after taking the other seat during the 2025 special election. She did not respond to a request for comment. 

Mavis Williams, a retired office manager, and Gregory Taylor, an Army veteran and school counselor, are set to be the council newcomers in 2027. Both have attributed their wins to residents’ overall discontent with the current council. 

They also each said by phone, as did Barker, that unease surrounding the possibility of a data center to the northeast of Marion also contributed to residents voting out incumbents.

In late October, the town released a statement announcing a developer was interested in about 200 acres of property owned by the town’s economic development authority — but council members and town staff wouldn’t say who the developer was or what it wanted to build. The acreage lies just outside town limits, so rezoning and permitting would be handled by Smyth County.

Rumors began to fly about the development being a data center after residents in the area said they spotted noise testing and core drilling equipment on the property. 

Several lined up to speak at the October and November meetings, which was held a day before the election, describing concerns about a data center’s toll on their utilities, property values and quality of life, as well as environmental impact. 

“I just wish the animosity from the spectators here would cease,” Carter said during the November meeting, after the public comment period was over. “Do they think the rest of the country is not watching this? Businesses are not going to want to come if they know they’re going to have a civil war every time something comes up. As old-timers used to say, you cut your nose off to spite your face.”

All current council members, except for Hunter Atwell, have not responded to requests for comment about the property. Atwell said by email he had not signed a nondisclosure agreement and pointed back to the town’s original statement, which does not name the developer. 

“Like other localities, we don’t make announcements based on anything short of certainties,” the statement said.

Williams said by phone that she believes the issues surrounding that piece of property had a major influence on the election results. It’s a common belief among Marion residents now that the current town council members keep secrets, she said, though she doesn’t think they’re doing it maliciously. She herself holds no animosity toward the council, she said.

“Citizens that attend meetings were so vocal about their dissatisfaction and kept saying, ‘You can be replaced,’” Williams said. “I think the citizens actually stirred the pot and made that happen. I don’t think it was me or anything I did.” 

Williams said information about the interested developer is so thin that she feels she can’t make any definitive statements yet about what she intends to advocate for in terms of what should be done with the land. If it does turn out to be a data center, she said there would need to be solid regulations on its construction and operations. 

There have been similar instances of disdain toward public input for several years, said Taylor, who was raised in Smyth County and moved to Marion in 2018. Like Barker, he thinks livestreaming the meetings has brought more attention to those problems, he said, combined with the beginning of the Facebook account Watchdogs of Marion, which was founded in late 2025. 

The account regularly circulates clips of council meetings and posts findings from records requests. It also posts about Smyth County government. Several Marion residents run the account together and attend meetings regularly. 

“The town has shown people this election that nobody’s safe,” Taylor said. “If we don’t do the bidding of the people, they’ll find someone else that will. I think now they’ll be more welcoming to scrutiny, or more welcoming to comments or opinions from people that aren’t on council.” 

The last time a Marion incumbent did not hold onto a seat was in 2024, when Carter lost, and before that was in 2014, when Barker lost a seat.