Protesters stand outside a data center developer open house, hosted by Fluidstack, in Wytheville. Photo by Siena Duncan.

Last December, a Wythe County Board of Supervisors meeting was standing room only.

Residents at the time said they were blindsided by the announcement of the first data center in the county, to be built on public land in an industrial park. The following year involved the announcement of a second, bigger data center on private land, sparking fears from local opponents that more were on the way. After an open house with one of the data center developers in October, many said they were still searching for answers. 

“Our ecosystems in Southwest Virginia are what make us so special,” said Maranda Edwards, a Wytheville resident, while at the open house. “We need to preserve that. People like looking out their windows and seeing the deer. With data centers, that’s going to go away, and that’s frustrating to know.”

For Edwards and her family members, who live out in the county, zoning regulations could have shone light on plans for the data centers before they were a done deal, she said. 

Wythe County is one of a handful of localities in Virginia that has no zoning codes. Data centers — or any other development — can be built on private land without public notice or government intervention aside from state permitting in limited circumstances. 

As of early November, the process to put codes in place has been progressing at the urging of dozens of county residents who say they want the regulations to act as a deterrent for data center developers. Several said that as conservatives who otherwise wouldn’t want zoning implemented, they see a need for it in their community because of data centers.

Across several counties in Southwest Virginia, a similar movement has taken root in meeting halls where officials have stressed the importance of getting specific data center zoning ordinances on the books. Most residents who speak at their public meetings have said they agree their localities need rules for data centers, though some are skeptical of their efficacy and have asked for multi-year moratoriums. 

No locality in Southwest Virginia has enacted a moratorium so far. For local governments, data centers can be a source of millions of dollars in property tax revenue, and some local officials have said they don’t want to write them off entirely. 

Wythe County zoning

In early November, the Wythe County Planning Commission voted 5-2 to send its drafted ordinance and map for a board of supervisors public hearing, the next step in a process to get zoning codes on record. The commission recommended a July 1 implementation date. 

A vote on the ordinance and the map would occur after the public hearing, which hasn’t been scheduled yet. 

Kate Franco, spokesperson for data center developer Fluidstack, speaks to Wythe County residents at an open house about a planned data center in a Wytheville industrial park. Photo by Siena Duncan.

The process started several years ago before data centers became a major concern for people in Wythe County, according to Matt Hankins, deputy county administrator. At the time, it was another major type of development rankling residents: solar farms.

In 2023, solar farm companies began building on hundreds of acres in the county, to the chagrin of residents around them, Hankins said in an interview. After looking at the options, he found the only way the county could make it possible to regulate solar farms on a local level was by enacting zoning codes. 

“We’ve had that conversation,” he said. “As part of it, residents said, ‘We’ve looked at zoning before. Come back to us with a light-touch ordinance that respects personal property rights and gives us some level of input and management over these projects as they come in.’”

The data center issue is similar in nature to solar farms, he said, and has motivated groups of residents to advocate for zoning. 

The ordinance he and his team have worked on isn’t perfect, Hankins said, but it reflects the character of the county and the end goal of putting it in place, which is to ensure public input for major changes to the county’s landscape.

The new codes would require a special exceptions permit for data centers, according to the draft document, which involves a public hearing and a vote from the board of supervisors. They would be allowed in commercial and industrial zones. Though some have called for a complete ban, Hankins said that it’s not legal to strike a particular use of private property from all areas of the county. 

The two data centers already in the works will also have to be grandfathered into the new codes, Hankins said. 

Wythe County residents have organized protests and spoken in droves at public meetings over the past year, asking for a way to halt the development of the data centers that have already been announced. They’ve voiced concerns over potential environmental impacts to the air and water, and the damage to their rural quality of life, if large-scale processing centers are built near their homes. 

At a public hearing hosted by the planning commission in late October, the majority of 17 people who spoke said they were in favor of zoning, specifically to protect the county from data centers. Those who were against zoning said they did not believe the codes would be protective enough against data centers to warrant restrictions on what they could do with their property. 

“Maybe we do need zoning to keep them out,” said Virginia Riggins, a county resident, during the October hearing. “But if they’re already here, it’s too late. Too little too late.” 

But for others, the possibility of Wythe County becoming a hotspot for dozens of data centers is the primary fear. 

Andrew Kegley has lived in the county for 46 years, he said in an interview. Like some, he believes the zoning has come too late, he said, but he is relieved it’s close to the finish line. He thinks it’s a dire need before other data center developers begin to see the county as a place to build without friction from the local government. 

He wants the effective date to be as soon as possible, he said. He advocated for Jan. 1 during the October hearing. 

“In an ideal world, we wouldn’t need zoning, nor would we be confronted with noxious developments like data centers or industrial solar, or whatever,” Kegley told the planning commissioners. “We don’t live in that ideal world, though… Timing will never be perfect. But more time without a zoning ordinance in place just means more time for undesirable projects to rear their ugly heads.”

The Wythe County Board of Supervisors is set to host the zoning public hearing Dec. 3 at Wytheville Community College, with a time to be determined, after a vote Thursday night.

Washington County vote

The Southwest Virginia locality that most recently adopted data center zoning regulations is Washington County. On Tuesday, its board of supervisors voted unanimously to integrate definitions for data centers and a special exception permit process for any developments. The ordinance would allow permit applications only in industrial zones. 

Unlike Wythe County, Washington County hasn’t been notified of any developers interested in building there, according to Stephen Richardson, the county’s planning commission coordinator. 

Protesters stand outside a data center developer open house, hosted by Fluidstack, in Wytheville. Photo by Siena Duncan.

The county has had zoning codes since the 1970s, but it hasn’t had any specific regulations for data centers up until now. The changes went into effect immediately.

“The county’s just wide open,” Richardson said ahead of the vote on the ordinance. 

During both a planning commission meeting in late October and the board of supervisors meeting, officials pointed out loose language and possible loopholes in the ordinance that could legally allow developers to skip the permitting process. 

But Richardson said multiple times that his concern was that any amendments would require more public hearings, pushing the approval process into January or later. It would be good to get something in writing now and then amend and tweak as the board of supervisors sees fit while protections are already in place, he said.

Supervisor Saul Hernandez pointed to a bill prefiled for the upcoming Virginia legislative session that, if passed, would enact a three-year data center moratorium across the state. 

It could actually motivate developers to move faster on properties they were considering in Virginia before the proposed law would go into effect next summer, Hernandez said. 

“I would imagine that’s why you’ve seen a lot of the activity — obviously not here, not in our county — but that’s why there’s urgency,” Hernandez said. “Maybe they see the writing on the wall, and they’re trying to get ahead of that moratorium.” 

The vast majority of dozens of people who spoke about the ordinance said they were in support of finding a way to slow down or prevent data center development. 

Julianne Miles, an Abingdon resident, said during the meeting that she hoped the board would consider revisiting the ordinance after it was passed, to tighten up the language. But she understands the need to pass it now, she said, referencing the moratorium bill. 

“If we don’t have something now, there’s a six-month window,” Miles said. “The potential of something coming in, in those next six months before we can get it perfect, is definitely there.” 

As part of the board’s vote, the supervisors set up a working group to review the ordinance and come up with changes. 

Similar to Wythe County, residents in Washington County have said they worry about the environment, their property values and the noise levels that could come with data center developments. Several have called for a moratorium during public meetings. 

County resident Marie Popiolek was the sole speaker against enacting the ordinance during the Tuesday meeting. She said she would rather have a moratorium than anything else. 

“We’ve seen corporations destroy environments, and the people that are left holding the bag are the citizens of that area,” she said. “So why not a moratorium?”

Richardson has said he is unsure whether the county has the authority to pass a moratorium, and the process to do so would likely take until into the new year. 

Other localities

Recently, other Southwest Virginia localities have put zoning regulations in place for data centers where they had none before. 

The city of Roanoke was one of the first, passing an ordinance in July requiring studies and construction standards for data centers and limiting them to a specific kind of industrial district through special exception permits. The city of Bristol passed a similar ordinance in early September.

Smyth County also adopted an ordinance in early September requiring special permits for data centers, when they could have been built without notice beforehand in industrial and commercial zones. 

Though Smyth County residents have had growing concerns about data centers, some have said they are dissatisfied with the new ordinance, because now data centers are technically allowed in agricultural zones as well. The issue is the subject of a lawsuit filed by Charles Wassum against the Smyth County Board of Supervisors. 

People who live in and around the town of Marion, Smyth County’s seat, have also said they’re worried a data center could be in the works just past the northeast boundary of town. The Marion Town Council put out a statement in early October that a developer was interested in about 200 acres of property owned by its economic development authority — but town officials have not named who the developer is or what could be built there. 

Over the past few months in Southside and Central Virginia, Amherst, Campbell and Henry counties have also amended their zoning ordinances to require special exception permits for data centers.

Julianne Miles speaks during a Washington County Board of Supervisors public hearing about her concerns about data centers in the county. Photo by Siena Duncan.